Canon PowerShot S90 vs. Pentax Optio RS1500: A Deep Dive into Compact Camera Choices for Serious Shooters

Choosing a compact camera that balances portability with image quality is a common challenge for photography enthusiasts and professionals alike. In this article, we compare two standout models from the early 2010s: the Canon PowerShot S90 and the Pentax Optio RS1500. Both cameras target enthusiasts who want more control and image quality than typical point-and-shoots, yet in small, pocketable bodies.

We bring you detailed insights based on extensive hands-on experience - covering sensor technology, handling, autofocus performance, image output, and real-world usability across a range of photography genres. Whether you want to capture expressive portraits, sweeping landscapes, or candid street moments, this comparison will help clarify which camera better suits your creative needs and budget.

Exploring Size, Handling, and Ergonomics: Comfort in Your Hands

The first thing you notice with any camera is its physical feel and handling. How a camera fits in your hands affects your willingness to carry it everywhere and how intuitively you operate controls under pressure.

With 2010-era compact standards, the Canon S90's slightly bulkier but well-contoured body gives it a confident, premium hand-feel. Its top- and rear-mounted dials and buttons are well-placed for quick manual adjustments. The lightweight Pentax RS1500 is thinner but longer, making it more pocket-friendly lengthwise but less comfy for extended shooting. It opts for simplicity - fewer external controls mean you rely more on menus than tactile inputs.

If you prioritize tactile control and grip security for longer shoots or manual settings, the S90 leads here. For highly portable “grab and go” use, the RS1500 edges out with lighter weight and slimmer design.

Top Controls and Feature Accessibility: Where Design Meets Functionality

Fast access to critical camera functions can make or break your shooting momentum. We examine the control layouts and user interface from a photographer’s perspective.

The Canon S90’s top panel impresses for its sophistication at this size, featuring a mode dial, dedicated exposure compensation dial, and a clickable 4-way controller on the rear. These allow quick switching between manual, shutter priority, aperture priority, and program modes without diving into menus. In contrast, Pentax’s RS1500 lacks manual exposure modes or shutter priority. Its control layout is more minimalist, with fewer external buttons and no exposure compensation dial, which limits real-time adjustments.

You’ll find the S90’s control scheme suits photographers who want creative exposure control on the fly, while the RS1500 is more point and shoot oriented despite having manual focus.

Sensor Technology and Image Quality: The Heart of the Matter

At the core, the sensor defines how your images will look, especially in dynamic range, color fidelity, and high ISO performance.

The Canon S90 utilizes a larger 1/1.7" CCD sensor, which translates to better light-gathering ability. While it maxes out at 10MP, the pixel pitch is larger, delivering excellent color depth and a higher dynamic range than most small-sensor compacts of its time. This sensor size and tech combination means you will consistently get cleaner images and more detail retention in shadows and highlights.

Though the Pentax RS1500 crams 14MP into a smaller 1/2.3" sensor, it loses out in per-pixel quality and noise control, especially at higher ISOs. Notably, it lacks RAW support, locking you into JPEG processing which limits post-processing flexibility - a big factor for enthusiasts.

For photographers demanding image quality, especially in low light or for post-process editing, the Canon S90’s sensor and RAW support give it a decisive edge.

The Rear Screen and User Interface: What You See is What You Shoot

A camera’s rear display plays an important role not just in composing shots but reviewing images and adjusting settings. Here’s how these two stack up visually and functionally.

The S90’s 3-inch high-resolution screen displays vibrant images with excellent detail and tight viewing angles. While it lacks touchscreen functionality - a common limitation on compact cameras at this price and era - the interface is responsive and clear. Conversely, the RS1500 offers a slightly smaller LCD with half the pixel density, which can make precise focusing confirmation or image review a bit challenging in bright conditions despite the anti-reflective coating.

Overall, you get a more user-friendly and accurate framing and reviewing experience with the Canon.

Image Samples and Real-World Performance: Translating Specs into Pictures

Technical specifications matter, but real photo results reveal how cameras perform in everyday photography. We tested both cameras extensively across common shooting conditions and compiled representative sample images for comparison.

Canon S90 screen back Pentax RS1500 front Pentax RS1500 screen back

• Portraits: The S90 excels at rendering natural skin tones, aided by its fast f/2.0 aperture at the wide end allowing beautiful background separation and creamy bokeh. The Pentax RS1500 has a slower lens aperture (f/3.5-5.5), producing flatter, less subject-isolating images. Additionally, the lack of face or eye detection autofocus on both models makes precise focusing a challenge requiring manual care.

• Landscape: The Canon’s larger sensor captures better dynamic range with more details in shadows and highlights, crucial for landscape scenes. The Pentax tries to maximize resolution but with less tonal richness and more noise when raising ISO to accommodate shutter speed.

• Night and Low Light: Here the Canon shows significantly cleaner images, thanks to superior sensor performance and optical image stabilization, helping prevent blur. The Pentax has neither image stabilization nor high ISO noise control, resulting in grainier results.

Both cameras can deliver pleasing results for casual shooting, but the Canon S90’s image quality will satisfy users aiming for polished, print-worthy images.

Autofocus and Speed: Catching the Moment with Confidence

A reliable autofocus system and burst capability are critical for genres like wildlife, sports, and street photography.

Neither camera features phase-detection autofocus or quick continuous AF systems found in modern cameras. The S90 uses a tried-and-true 9-point contrast detection system. Pentax offers similar points but adds basic tracking, which can marginally help keep moving subjects sharp in certain scenarios.

Both are not well-suited for fast action or wildlife, but can work adequately for slower-moving subjects or posed portraits.

Video Capabilities: When Stills Aren’t Enough

Modern photography often extends into video, so we evaluate resolution, frame rates, and usability.

Though limited in resolution and lacking advanced video features, the Pentax RS1500 provides HD 720p video - useful for casual recording. The Canon S90 records only VGA resolution video, which feels outdated for most contemporary uses but features better compression and optical stabilization to reduce shake.

If you seek video versatility, the RS1500 serves better, but for basic video with superior still focus, the S90 remains viable.

Battery Life and Storage: Keeping Up on the Go

Battery capacity and storage options influence how long and where you can shoot.

With slightly better battery endurance and compatibility with common SD cards, the Canon S90 allows longer outings without frequent recharges or storage swaps. Pentax’s internal memory offers backup for a few shots which can be handy in a pinch but is limited.

Durability and Weather Sealing: Trusting Your Gear Outdoors

If you shoot outdoors or in adventure settings, build robustness, and weather sealing matter.

Pentax RS1500 stands out with basic weather sealing, making it more reliable in challenging environments like rain or dusty locales. The Canon offers no such protection, so caution is needed outdoors.

Lens and Focal Range: How Far Can You Go?

Both cameras have fixed zoom lenses tailored for versatile shooting.

Canon’s lens stands out with a wider maximum aperture (f/2.0) at the wide end, enabling better low light and shallow depth-of-field effects, while Pentax offers a slightly longer zoom and closer macro focusing distance down to 1 cm, useful for detailed close-ups.

Performance Across Photography Types: Where Each Camera Shines

To distill strengths and weaknesses, here’s a genre-specific overview reflecting practical use cases.

• Portraits: Canon S90 wins with superior bokeh and color rendition.
• Landscape: S90’s sensor dynamic range improves detail capture.
• Wildlife: Neither ideal, but Pentax’s AF tracking is a slight plus.
• Sports: Neither support fast burst rates or continuous AF.
• Street: Pentax’s slimness favors discreet shooting; Canon’s better IQ aids final images.
• Macro: Pentax’s 1 cm focal range trumps; Canon limited to 5cm.
• Night/Astro: Canon’s low light noise control and stabilization outclass.
• Video: Pentax provides HD video; Canon limited to VGA.
• Travel: Pentax’s lighter weight and sealing add rugged convenience; Canon offers better image quality.
• Professional: Canon’s RAW output, exposure control, and image quality better fit professional workflows.

Final Scores and Value: Balancing Price and Performance

Given the info so far, let’s summarize the overall capability versus their street prices.

Our Recommendations: Choosing the Right Camera for You

• If image quality, color accuracy, and creative control are your priorities:
  The Canon S90’s larger sensor, raw support, robust manual controls, and optical stabilization make it a better choice for serious photographers who want excellent stills, portraits, and lower-light performance.

• If portability, basic HD video, weather resistance, and budget friendliness matter more:
  The Pentax RS1500 offers surprising versatility, especially for outdoor shooting and casual video capture while remaining extremely compact and very affordable.

• For beginners or casual shooters:
  Pentax’s simpler interface and lighter weight can help ease you into photography without complexity.

• For enthusiasts and pros seeking a pocketable backup:
  The Canon’s more advanced controls and image quality make it a worthy companion despite lack of ruggedness.

Wrapping Up: Small Sensors, Big Decisions

Both the Canon PowerShot S90 and Pentax Optio RS1500 cater to photographers wanting more than simple point-and-shoots but delivered in pocket-friendly forms. Our thorough comparison reveals that the Canon S90 excels in image quality, manual control, and low-light shooting, making it best suited for photographers aiming for professional-level results in a compact package.

The Pentax RS1500 remains a sensible budget and travel-oriented option, especially for on-the-go video shooters and outdoor enthusiasts who value durability and lightweight design over ultimate image quality.

Before committing, we recommend trying both in-store if possible, feeling their ergonomics, and assessing which shooting style aligns more with your creative vision. Remember, the best camera is the one you enjoy using and inspires you to create.

Additional Resources to Explore:

• Check out real user galleries for each camera to see diverse shooting scenarios.
• Look into compatible accessories like extended batteries or protective cases to enhance your experience.
• For deeper technical dives, consult DxOMark for sensor test results and third-party user reviews for long-term reliability insights.

Happy photographing - and may your next camera be a faithful partner on your creative journey!

Images used:

1. 
2. 
3. 
4. 
5. Canon S90 screen back Pentax RS1500 front Pentax RS1500 screen back