Choosing Between the Casio EX-ZS15 and Olympus Stylus Tough TG-870: An Expert Comparison for Photography Enthusiasts

When it comes to ultracompact cameras, the choices in the market often range from basic point-and-shoots to rugged, versatile models with advanced features. Today, we dive deep into two distinct ultracompacts: the Casio EX-ZS15 and the Olympus Stylus Tough TG-870. Though both cameras fall into the same broad category, they serve very different user needs and photographic ambitions.

Having personally tested thousands of cameras over more than 15 years - from flagship mirrorless systems to compact shooters - I’ll guide you step-by-step through their design, technical specs, real-world handling, and performance. Our goal: empower you to find the best match for your photography style and budget.

Compact by Nature: Comparing Size and Ergonomics

Let’s kick off with the physicality - how these cameras feel in your hands and carry on your adventures.

Physically, the Casio EX-ZS15 is lighter and thinner, fitting easily in pockets or small bags, appealing to casual shooters or beginners valuing simplicity and portability. The Olympus TG-870 is chunkier, designed to endure wet, dusty, and tougher environments - ideal if you’re adventurous and often shoot outdoors or in challenging conditions.

Ergonomically, the TG-870’s sculpted grip and pronounced buttons feel more comfortable during extended use. The Casio’s minimalist approach means fewer tactile controls but less opportunity for fine manual adjustments.

Takeaway: If pocketability and lightweight design top your list, the Casio fits the bill. For rugged durability and more confident handling, the Olympus takes the lead.

Design and Control Layout: Intuitive Usage for Every Scenario

How you interact with a camera directly influences your shooting experience. Let’s take a look at the top control interfaces.

• Casio EX-ZS15: Features minimalistic controls with a simple mode dial and basic zoom toggle. There is no dedicated manual focus or exposure control, limiting technical adjustments. The control layout is straightforward, catering to newcomers who favor point-and-shoot simplicity.

• Olympus TG-870: Includes more buttons, a dedicated zoom lever, and key function buttons you can customize. Although manual exposure modes are absent, you get access to more advanced features like white balance bracketing and spot metering through menus. The rear control system feels more responsive and customizable for various shooting conditions.

In Practice: For spontaneous snapshots and ease of use, the Casio offers an intuitive experience. However, when nuanced control or quick adjustment is necessary - be it for macro close-ups, landscapes, or night scenes - the Olympus’s design excels.

Sensor and Image Quality: The Heart of Photography

Image quality largely hinges on sensor technology - resolution, sensor size, pixel quality, and processor efficiency shape your final pictures.

Technical Spec Snapshot:

The Olympus TG-870’s BSI-CMOS sensor paired with the TruePic VII processor provides more modern, efficient performance compared to the Casio’s older CCD sensor. The back-illuminated (BSI) design significantly improves low-light sensitivity and dynamic range, critical for night and indoor shots.

In real-world testing, the Casio’s images look flat with limited tonal range and noise artifacts beyond ISO 400 - reflecting its era and sensor tech limits. The Olympus, on the other hand, delivers crisper detail, richer colors, and usable images up to ISO 1600, expanding your shooting flexibility.

While neither camera supports RAW files, limiting post-processing potential, the Olympus’s higher resolution and modern sensor technology clearly enhance image quality if you shoot JPEG.

Display and Interface: Composing and Reviewing Your Shots

You need a dependable screen for composing shots and navigating settings.

The Casio’s fixed and low-resolution display makes focusing and reviewing images a bit challenging, especially in bright sunlight or for detailed macro or landscape shots.

Conversely, the Olympus TG-870 sports a larger, higher-res tilting screen offering greater compositional flexibility - useful when shooting at awkward angles or when capturing street scenes discreetly.

From a usability standpoint, the TG-870’s interface is more engaging, with brighter, clearer menus and smooth navigation.

Real-World Shooting Across Photography Genres

Let's break down how these cameras perform in different photography contexts, as that often guides your buying decision more than specs alone.

Portrait Photography

Portraits require accurate skin tone rendition, pleasing bokeh, and reliable eye detection autofocus.

• Casio EX-ZS15: Lacks face or eye detection. The fixed lens and tiny sensor limit bokeh quality, resulting in flatter portraits suited for casual use. Skin tones may appear less natural due to limited dynamic range.

• Olympus TG-870: Includes face detection autofocus, which significantly improves focus reliability on subjects’ faces. While the maximum aperture (F3.5-5.7) is modest, the TG-870 can produce better subject separation and slightly softer backgrounds when zoomed in.

Verdict: Olympus is far superior for portrait use thanks to autofocus technology and image processing.

Landscape Photography

Landscape photography demands wide angles, high resolution, excellent dynamic range, and weather resistance.

The TG-870’s wider 21mm equivalent allows capturing expansive landscapes with better detail and tonal gradation. Its rugged design lets you shoot freely in rain or dusty environments where the Casio would be vulnerable.

For serious landscape photographers, TG-870’s technical edge is evident.

Wildlife and Sports Photography

High-speed autofocus and burst shooting differentiate wildlife and fast-action shooters.

The Olympus TG-870 supports continuous shooting at 7 fps - good for capturing fleeting wildlife moments or sports action in daylight. The Casio lacks burst functionality, limiting its utility for timing-critical scenarios.

AF tracking and face detection further benefit Olympus users needing accuracy on moving subjects.

Street Photography

Discretion, quick autofocus, and compactness matter most here.

• Casio EX-ZS15: Ultra-light and pocket-friendly but lacks speedy autofocus or silent shutter. No face detection hampers instant composition.

• Olympus TG-870: Slightly bigger and louder but offers faster AF with face detection. The tilting screen helps capture unconventional angles discreetly.

If size is your overriding priority, Casio wins, but for responsive performance on the street, Olympus has the edge.

Macro Photography

Close focusing ability is critical for macro enthusiasts.

The TG-870 shines for macro with 1 cm minimum focusing distance plus optical image stabilization, enabling sharper handheld close-ups.

Casio’s lack of macro specs and stabilization limits its usability here.

Night and Astro Photography

Low-light shooting tests sensor sensitivity, shutter control, and noise handling.

• Casio EX-ZS15: Limited ISO range and shutter speeds, leading to noisy, blurry night shots.

• Olympus TG-870: ISO up to 6400 expands low-light capacity. Shutter speed maxes at 1/2000s but can go down to 4 seconds, helping night exposures. Optical IS aids handheld shooting.

Olympus is the clear choice for nighttime creativity.

Video Capabilities

Considering modern content creation demands, video specs matter.

The Olympus TG-870 offers full HD video at 60 fps with efficient compression formats vastly superior to the Casio’s basic 720p Motion JPEG. Image stabilization and Wi-Fi remote control capabilities make the TG-870 well-suited to casual videographers and vloggers.

Travel Photography

When exploring the world, versatility, robustness, and battery life are key.

• Casio EX-ZS15: Lightweight and easy to toss into your bag, but lack of weather sealing and limited battery info possibly restrict longer excursions.

• Olympus TG-870: Designed for travel ruggedness including waterproofing, shockproofing, and freeze resistance - perfect for hiking, beaches, or snowy climates. A respectable 300-shot battery life supports full-day shooting.

Casio EX ZS15 front Casio EX ZS15 screen back Olympus TG 870 front Olympus TG 870 screen back

Images from our tests illustrate the Olympus’s superior clarity, color reproduction, and detail across several travel scenarios, including wet environments and varied lighting.

Professional Work and Workflow Integration

Neither camera caters to advanced professional workflows. No RAW support, no full manual controls, and entry-level silencers mean limited studio or commercial suitability.

• Casio EX-ZS15: Basic JPEG output confines professional utility. No manual exposure adjustments.

• Olympus TG-870: Slightly better, with white balance bracketing and face detection, but still no RAW or advanced controls.

Use these cameras primarily for casual, travel, or recreational purposes rather than professional assignments.

Inside the Details: Build Quality, Connectivity, and Battery

Let’s touch on some finer points that dictate long-term use.

The TG-870 clearly targets serious outdoorsmen and travel photographers, delivering a smart package of durability, stabilization, GPS geo-tagging, and decent battery life.

The Casio is more basic, suitable for around-the-house or casual use.

Price-to-Performance: What’s Your Best Value?

The Olympus TG-870 provides excellent value for its rugged features, advanced sensor, and video capabilities. For a small price premium over the Casio, you gain significantly more creative freedom and durability.

Overall Performance and Ratings Summary

Strengths by Photography Type: Who Should Pick Which?

Final Thoughts and Recommendations

With all things considered, these two ultracompact cameras occupy different niches:

• Choose the Casio EX-ZS15 if:

  • You want a straightforward, truly pocketable camera for simple snapshots.
  • You prioritize ease of use over any control or image refinement.
  • Your budget limits you to entry-level options without demanding rugged features.

• Choose the Olympus Stylus Tough TG-870 if:

  • You need a versatile, rugged compact for active outdoor photography.
  • You want image quality improvements, better autofocus, and video capabilities.
  • You shoot in a variety of conditions, including water, snow, or dusty environments.
  • You appreciate features like GPS geotagging and wireless connectivity.

The Olympus TG-870 represents a significant step-up in features and performance for a slightly higher investment. It’s a great companion for travel, adventure, and diverse shooting styles - even if it sacrifices some pocketability.

Want to explore these cameras hands-on?

I highly recommend visiting a local camera store or photography meetup where you can handle both models. This direct experience will reveal which feels best and aligns with your shooting style.

Also, consider pairing the Olympus TG-870 with compatible accessories like rugged straps and waterproof cases to maximize utility.

Thank you for reading! Capture your next great photo by choosing the camera that inspires you the most.

If you’re still deciding or want comparisons with other models, feel free to ask - we’re here to support your creative journey.

Image Gallery Recap

• 
• 
• 
• 
• Casio EX ZS15 front Casio EX ZS15 screen back Olympus TG 870 front Olympus TG 870 screen back