Nikon Z5 vs Panasonic Lumix S5: A Deep Dive Into These Two Full-Frame Mirrorless Contenders

When it comes to full-frame mirrorless cameras that blend professional capabilities with approachable price points, the Nikon Z5 and Panasonic Lumix S5 frequently appear on the shortlist. Both launched in 2020, these mirrorless cameras cater to enthusiasts and prosumers seeking versatile tools for stills and video. But how do they really stack up when taking a hands-on look at real-world photography and videography?

Having tested both models extensively across multiple shooting scenarios - from portraiture to wildlife, landscapes to nightscapes - I’ll unpack their technical strengths, practical performance, and value propositions. Whether you're a portrait artist, an aspiring videographer, or a travel photographer hunting for the perfect hybrid, this detailed comparison is designed to guide your decision.

First Impressions: How They Feel and Fit In Your Hands

Handling a camera can tell you a lot about its suitability for your workflow and shooting style. Let's start with size and ergonomics.

• Nikon Z5 - The Z5 feels solid yet very manageable in the hand, with dimensions of 134x101x70 mm and a weight of 675 grams. Its SLR-style body has a notably deep grip that offers comfort during extended shoots. The balance with pro-grade Z-mount lenses is excellent, helping with stability especially when shooting handheld.

• Panasonic S5 - The Lumix S5 is a smidge heavier at 714 grams but slightly more compact in length and height (133x97x82 mm). It leans toward a slimmer profile but with a grip that’s less pronounced than the Z5’s. If you prefer a streamlined form factor that's easy to slip into a travel bag without bulk, the S5 shines here.

Both cameras come with weather sealing, protecting you from dust and splashes, essential for working outdoors or in less-than-ideal weather. Neither is fully weatherproof, so heavy rain demands some caution.

In terms of user interface, the arrangement of dials and buttons given the camera style influences how quickly you can adapt and navigate menus.

• Z5 Controls - Nikon’s top control layout offers a dedicated ISO dial and a second command dial on the grip, which photographers appreciate for manual exposure adjustments. The mode and exposure compensation dials are tactile and robust, appealing if you shoot in aperture priority or manual modes often.

• S5 Controls - Panasonic opts for a more streamlined setup, omitting a dedicated ISO dial in favor of dial control via the rear wheel and touchscreen. Its fully articulating screen complements video shooters and vloggers nicely (we’ll get to displays a bit later).

Sensor and Image Quality: The Heart of the Matter

Your image quality boils down to sensor technology and processing. Both cameras pack 24-megapixel full-frame CMOS sensors, but there are some important differences.

• Detail and Sharpness: The Z5’s sensor includes an anti-alias filter, which slightly reduces moiré but can soften fine detail compared to the S5’s no-AA sensor that prioritizes maximum sharpness and detail. In practice, the difference is subtle but noticeable especially when working with fine textures or landscape details.

• ISO Performance: Panasonic’s S5 offers an extended ISO boost up to 204,800, double the Z5’s max of 102,400. Our low-light testing shows the S5 handles noise marginally better at very high ISO values, with cleaner shadows and less color degradation. However, both deliver excellent quality up to ISO 6400–12800, perfectly suitable for the majority of shooting scenarios.

• Dynamic Range: Although no DXO marks are available, both cameras’ sensors deliver between 13-14 stops of dynamic range in RAW files - standard for high-end full-frame models. This translates into rich tonality for landscape photographers capturing high-contrast scenes.

For photographers wanting the quintessential “filmic” rendering and punchy color science, the Nikon tends to produce a cooler, more neutral palette, whereas Panasonic’s colors skew a bit warmer and more contrasty out of camera.

Viewing and Interface: Keeping Your Eye on the Prize

Image composition and review depend heavily on viewfinder quality and rear screen usability.

• Viewfinder:

  • The Z5 sports a 3.69 million-dot OLED EVF with 0.8x magnification, giving a bright, detailed, lag-free view.
  • The S5’s OLED EVF is 2.36 million dots with 0.74x magnification. While slightly lower resolution, it remains crisp and responsive.

• Rear Screen:

  • Nikon’s 3.2” tilting LCD has a modest 1.04 million-dot resolution; good for framing but limiting for detailed image review or video work.
  • Panasonic offers a fully articulating 3.0” touchscreen with a hefty 1.84 million dots, ideal for vloggers, selfie shooters, and video creators aiming for flexible framing.

Touch responsiveness is excellent on both, but the Panasonic’s articulating screen will be particularly appreciated when shooting from awkward angles, doing self-record, or tethered capture.

Autofocus and Performance: Getting the Shot When It Counts

Autofocus speed and accuracy are critical under pressure - be it snapping a fast-moving sprint or capturing subtle wildlife gestures.

• Nikon Z5: Uses a sophisticated hybrid AF system that combines phase detection and contrast detection, delivering fast acquisition and tracking including human and animal eye AF. This is a boon for portraits, wildlife enthusiasts, and pet photographers who rely on sharp, expressive eyes.

• Panasonic S5: Employs a contrast-detection AF system enhanced by Panasonic’s Depth From Defocus technology. It handles stationary subjects well but can struggle to lock precisely on fast-moving animals. However, thanks to a higher continuous shooting rate of 7 fps and a larger buffer, the S5 benefits action and street photographers who shoot bursts frequently.

In low light, the Z5 shows slightly better AF reliability due to its phase detection across the sensor, whereas the S5 compensates by offering excellent image stabilization (more on that shortly) to avoid blur.

Exploring Photography Genres: Which Model Excels Where?

Let's get practical - how do these cameras handle different photography styles? We've tested sample images for each discipline to highlight real outcomes.

Nikon Z5 front Nikon Z5 screen back Panasonic S5 front Panasonic S5 screen back

Portrait Photography

• Z5: With its animal eye AF and reliable human face detection, the Z5 excels at capturing expressive, tack-sharp portraits. Combined with the Nikon Z lens lineup’s renowned bokeh and sharpness, skin tones come out natural and flattering. The tilting screen presents some challenges with low-angle composition but remains sufficient for traditional portrait setups.

• S5: While lacking animal eye AF, Panasonic’s S5 delivers accurate and fast face detection. The fully articulating screen is perfect for creative angles and video portraits. The no-AA sensor combined with sharp Leica L lenses yields very detailed skin texture capture, but sometimes at the cost of slight oversharpening.

Landscape Photography

• Z5: The Z5’s sensor and robust dynamic range shine for landscape photographers capturing vibrant skies and subtle shadow detail. Its anti-alias filter smooths moiré when photographing textured subjects like grasses or patterned rocks. Good weather sealing provides confidence shooting in challenging outdoor environments.

• S5: Panasonic edges the Z5 slightly on resolution and detail due to no AA filter and higher pixel-level sharpness. Its low weight and compact size make it a great hike companion. However, battery life is shorter than Nikon’s, so plan accordingly.

Wildlife Photography

• Z5: The edge goes to the Z5 with its hybrid AF and animal eye detection - essential for fast animal portraits and tracking. Though its 4.5 fps burst rate is modest, the autofocus accuracy ensures usable frames in unpredictable wildlife moments.

• S5: Faster 7 fps shooting helps capture rapid sequences, but lack of animal eye AF and reliance on contrast AF makes locking on wildlife eyes more challenging. Effective image stabilization supports shooting with longer lenses handheld.

Sports Photography

• Z5: The 4.5 fps continuous shooting speed limits fast-paced sports shooting, making it less optimal for subjects like football or basketball. Tracking AF is accurate, but buffer size restricts continuous bursts.

• S5: 7 fps shooting and larger buffer make the S5 a better performer for moderate-speed action sports. Still, with contrast AF, subject tracking is less reliable at extreme speeds.

Street Photography

• Z5: Its robust build and larger grip mean it’s not the most discreet for street photography, but image quality and quiet shutter modes offset that. The tilting screen is limited for self-framing.

• S5: Compact form, silent electronic shutter mode, and fully articulating screen make the S5 the better street camera option, allowing creative angles and vlog-friendly engagement.

Macro Photography

• Z5: Reliable autofocus with focus bracketing support helps create sharp focus stacks. Sensor stabilization aids handheld macro shoots.

• S5: Also supports focus stacking and boasts stronger image stabilization, helping capture extreme close-ups with minimal shake.

Night and Astro Photography

• Z5: Larger, cleaner ISO performance up to 12800 makes the Z5 excellent for star fields and nightscapes. The good dynamic range aids in retrieving dark shadow detail.

• S5: Extended ISO options and improved stabilization help too, but sensor noise at extremely high ISO can be noticeable. The fully articulated screen helps with composing in the dark.

Video Capabilities

When talking hybrid shooters, video specs are crucial.

The Panasonic S5 clearly positions itself as the more serious hybrid camera for video creators. It supports 4K/60p recording with high bit rates, V-Log capture for color grading, and advanced image stabilization suitable for handheld footage. The fully articulating screen aids vloggers and solo shooters.

The Z5, meanwhile, offers solid 4K/30p capture and clean audio options but is less expandable for professional video workflows.

Build Quality, Durability, and Battery Life

Both cameras are engineered for workflow reliability, but there are notable differences.

• Nikon Z5: Featuring a magnesium alloy chassis and weather sealing, the Z5 weighs 675 g and offers a generous battery life of 470 shots per charge (CIPA standard). Dual UHS-II SD card slots speak to professional needs for backup and storage flexibility.

• Panasonic S5: Magnesium alloy body with weather sealing is similar, weighing slightly more at 714 g. Battery life rates around 440 shots, and dual SD card slots (UHS-II compatible) are present. The S5 stands out with USB-C charging that supports high-power charging from laptops or power banks - a boon for travel.

Lens Ecosystem and Compatibility

Your choice may depend on lens availability and system investment.

• Nikon Z5: Uses Nikon’s Z-mount, which now boasts 15 native lenses - a growing lineup including sharp primes and versatile zooms. The gap has narrowed quickly, and Nikon’s F-mount lens adapters unlock a vast legacy lens base for manual or autofocus.

• Panasonic S5: Fits Leica L-mount lenses, supported by the L-Mount Alliance (Panasonic, Leica, Sigma) with 31 native lenses and counting. The agreement ensures a healthy supply of high-quality options, making it an attractive platform for photographers valuing choice and innovation.

Connectivity and Workflow Integration

• Both cameras provide built-in Wi-Fi and Bluetooth for remote control and image transfer. Panasonic supports USB charging and tethering with laptop power banks, beneficial for on-location timelapses or studio work.

• Nikon’s EN-EL15c battery is common within Nikon's ecosystem, easing battery swaps if you own other Nikon gear.

Price and Value: Which Gives You More?

At $600 difference, the Panasonic S5 targets hybrid creators prioritizing video and versatility, while the Nikon Z5 offers a more affordable entry to full-frame mirrorless with strong photography tools.

Comprehensive Performance Ratings

To summarize overall capabilities, here are our expert-assessed scores based on extended testing.

Genre-Specific Strengths

• Portraits: Nikon Z5 slightly ahead for eye AF and skin rendition
• Landscape: Panasonic S5's no-AA sensor edges Nikon in resolution/detail
• Wildlife: Nikon Z5 favored due to eye AF and tracking
• Sports: Panasonic S5 due to faster burst and buffer
• Street: Panasonic S5 preferred for portability and silent shutter
• Macro: Panasonic S5 for focus stacking capabilities
• Night/Astro: Nikon Z5’s cleaner ISO handling prevails
• Video: Panasonic S5 with superior codec support and 4K60p capture
• Travel: Panasonic S5 with versatile screen and USB power charging
• Pro Work: Nikon Z5 with greater battery stamina and Nikon ecosystem

Final Thoughts and Recommendations: Find Your Fit

The Nikon Z5 is ideal if you:

• Prioritize still photography with strong autofocus and eye detection, especially for portraits and wildlife.
• Want a comfortable, robust grip with traditional control dials.
• Need longer battery life for extended sessions without frequent recharging.
• Seek a more budget-friendly entry into full-frame mirrorless.
• Prefer shooting with deep access to Nikon’s Z lens ecosystem and legacy lenses.

The Panasonic Lumix S5 is ideal if you:

• Are a hybrid shooter with significant video demands, especially capturing 4K at 60p.
• Value a fully articulating touchscreen for creative shooting angles and vlogging.
• Appreciate faster continuous shooting rates for action, street, or wildlife bursts.
• Want advanced stabilization combined with flexible shooting features like 4K photo modes.
• Prefer a lighter, more compact body for travel and casual shooting.

Getting Started and Choosing Accessories

If you decide between these cameras, consider investing in native lenses to maximize performance. The Nikon Z5 pairs well with the Z 24-70mm f/4 S for versatility or the nifty Z 50mm f/1.8 S for portraits. For the Panasonic S5, the Leica DG Vario-Elmarit 12-60mm f/2.8-4 zoom is a great all-rounder.

Also, explore professional tripods, external microphones, and extra batteries to expand your shooting possibilities.

Summary

Both the Nikon Z5 and Panasonic S5 offer compelling full-frame mirrorless solutions tailored to different creator needs. Nikon shines with excellent stills autofocus, ergonomics, and battery life, while Panasonic excels in video versatility and speed.

By honestly assessing your priorities - whether that’s still photography finesse or hybrid video workflows - you can confidently select the tool that fuels your creative vision.

To truly appreciate each camera’s potential, I encourage you to test their handling and menus in person, review sample images and videos, and consider the lenses you want to use. These hands-on experiences will illuminate the model best made for your photographic journey.

Happy shooting!

END