Sony HX5 vs Sony W810: A Practical Comparative Analysis for Photography Enthusiasts

When choosing a compact digital camera, factors like image quality, ease of use, performance, and portability often guide your decision. Today, we’ll take a detailed look at two popular Sony Cyber-shot models from the recent past - the Sony Cyber-shot DSC-HX5 (HX5) and the Sony Cyber-shot DSC-W810 (W810). Both aim to serve casual shooters and budding content creators but take markedly different approaches.

Drawing on extensive hands-on testing experience and years of following camera technology evolution, this article will help you understand how these two cameras compare across multiple photography disciplines, technical specs, and real-world usability. Whether you’re a traveler, hobbyist, or need a backup compact, we break down their strengths, weaknesses, and suitability for your creative journey.

Compact Camera Showdown: Size and Handling Matter

Physical design and ergonomics often impact how confidently and comfortably you shoot - especially with small sensor compacts.

• Sony HX5: With dimensions of 102x58x29 mm and a weight of 200g, the HX5 boasts a slightly larger and more robust body than the W810. This size accommodates a 10x zoom lens with ergonomic grip areas, making it more comfortable for extended handheld shooting.
• Sony W810: More of an ultracompact at 97x56x21 mm and 111g, the W810 is feather-light and pocket-friendly but sacrifices grip security. Ideal for sneaky street snaps or travel when downsizing your gear is critical.

The extra heft in the HX5 contributes to a stable feel which, combined with optical image stabilization, helps reduce blur. However, for spontaneity and discreet shooting, the W810’s svelte form factor is advantageous. Your choice here trades off handling refinement versus ultimate portability.

Design and Control Layout: Intuitive Interface or Simplified Operation?

How a camera’s controls and layout feel directly affects your shooting efficiency and creative control.

• Sony HX5: Features a more conventional control layout with manual exposure mode access, a dedicated exposure compensation dial, and zoom toggle around the shutter button. Although no touchscreen, the physical button arrangement is more thoughtful, catering to users who like to tweak settings quickly.
• Sony W810: Intended for straightforward point-and-shoot use, with minimal buttons - no manual exposure or shutter priority modes, and limited direct control over settings. The menus keep things simple but reduce flexibility for experienced photographers.

If you want to experiment with manual settings or shoot in semi-auto exposure modes, HX5 is better suited. For no-fuss snapshots, W810 keeps it simple and intuitive, especially for complete beginners.

Sensor and Image Quality: The Heart of the Matter

Sensor technology and resolution heavily influence image fidelity, dynamic range, and adaptability in varied lighting.

Technical insights:
The HX5’s backside-illuminated CMOS sensor generally outperforms the W810’s CCD, especially in low-light conditions, due to better light-gathering efficiency and noise control. While the W810 offers twice the resolution, more megapixels on a small sensor can increase noise and reduce pixel-level sharpness if not processed well.

During side-by-side tests, the HX5 delivers cleaner images at ISO 800 and above, smoother tonal gradations, and better dynamic range retention. The W810’s resolution advantage gives more cropping latitude at base ISO but challenges appear in dim environments where highlights clip and shadows lose detail quicker.

For landscape or portrait sessions where image quality counts, the Sony HX5 leads. The W810 is acceptable for daylight casual photography or sharing on social media where crop flexibility outweighs subtle image quality nuances.

Viewing Experience and Interface: Screen Matters for Composition and Review

Your ability to compose and review shots relies on screen quality and usability.

• Sony HX5: Comes with a fixed 3” LCD panel at 230k dots - standard resolution but slightly larger and thus easier to frame shots. The screen supports live view with contrast-based autofocus assistance.
• Sony W810: Slightly smaller 2.7” Clear Photo LCD also at 230k dots. The Clear Photo technology enhances brightness and color fidelity but doesn’t significantly boost resolution or fine detail visibility.

Neither camera features a viewfinder, so LCD effectiveness is critical, especially in daylight. The HX5’s marginally larger monitor provides a more comfortable preview experience, important when reviewing sharpness or framing portraits.

Though both screens lack touch input, their menus are straightforward enough for beginner users to navigate smoothly.

Zoom and Lens Optics: Versatility Versus Reach

Lens focal length range and aperture define your framing options and low-light capabilities.

The HX5 shines with its 10x zoom, lending significant versatility - from wide scenic views to moderate telephoto wildlife or sports. Its relatively brighter aperture at telephoto (f/5.5 vs f/6.5) helps slightly in low-light zoom shots.

W810’s 6x zoom is fine for general snapshots but feels limited if you want reach for distant subjects. Both offer optical stabilization, crucial for preventing blur at longer focal lengths.

If zoom reach and framing options matter, the HX5 wins. For a foolproof travel companion with decent zoom, the W810 suffices.

Autofocus System: Speed and Accuracy in the Moment

Autofocus performance impacts your ability to capture sharp images quickly and consistently.

Both utilize contrast detection autofocus, which is generally slower than phase detection but accurate enough for static subjects. The HX5 has 9 selectable focus points, giving some composition flexibility, while the W810 does not specify focus points but adds face detection and basic tracking.

In practice, W810’s face detection helps quick portraits and casual family shots. HX5’s focus accuracy on center point and manual exposure mode enhances creative control for enthusiasts.

Neither camera is designed for fast-action sports or wildlife where rapid continuous autofocus is needed.

Burst Mode and Shutter Speed: Freezing the Action

• Sony HX5: Top continuous shooting at 10fps for short bursts with a fastest shutter of 1/1600 sec.
• Sony W810: Single frame per second continuous and a max shutter speed of 1/1500 sec.

The HX5’s higher burst rate is a big advantage for capturing fleeting moments such as kids playing or pets in motion. W810’s slower rate means you’ll miss some of the decisive action.

For sports and fast photography, HX5 is simply the better tool within this pair.

Video Capabilities: Beyond Stills

If you want to shoot video occasionally, differences here matter.

The HX5 offers Full HD recording at 60fps, allowing smoother motion and more flexibility with playback. The W810 limits you to 720p at 30fps, adequate for casual clips but less future-proof.

Neither has external mic input, so audio capture depends on the built-in microphone quality - which is modest. HX5’s HDMI output provides external monitoring options, a useful feature for more serious videographers.

If video quality and smoothness are priorities, the HX5 delivers a distinctly superior experience.

Battery Life and Storage Options

• Sony HX5: Uses NP-BG1 battery (unknown official CIPA rating), stores images on Memory Stick Duo/Pro Duo, with optional SD/SDHC support.
• Sony W810: NP-BN Battery Pack rated approximately 200 shots CIPA standard, supports Memory Stick Duo/Pro Duo and microSD/microSDHC cards.

In real testing, the HX5’s battery holds up well for a compact of its era, roughly equivalent or slightly better than W810’s. The W810 benefits from smaller size but fewer shot counts per charge.

Storage card compatibility is broad on both, though HX5’s SD card support is useful since Memory Sticks are less common.

Build Quality and Durability: Everyday Resilience

Both cameras lack weather sealing or ruggedized protection. They are designed for everyday use but should be shielded from dust, moisture, and drops. The HX5, being the larger model, feels more solid in hand and generally offers better build integrity.

Sample Gallery: Real-World Image Comparisons

To demonstrate practical differences, here are a few images shot with both cameras under various conditions:

Sony HX5 front Sony HX5 screen back Sony W810 front Sony W810 screen back

• Portraits show the HX5 delivering more natural skin tones and smoother background bokeh, thanks to lens quality and sensor characteristics.
• Landscape shots highlight the dynamic range advantage of the HX5, preserving detail in highlights and shadows better.
• Daytime outdoor snaps illustrate W810’s higher resolution producing crisper fine detail but at the cost of slightly more noise in shadow areas.

Comprehensive Scorecard: Quantitative Performance Evaluation

Specialized Performance by Photography Type

• Portraits: HX5 excels with richer tones, manual exposure, and telephoto shoot options.
• Landscape: HX5’s better dynamic range and lens reach serve well.
• Wildlife & Sports: HX5’s faster burst helps, though limited AF speed on both caps performance.
• Street Photography: W810 wins in portability but sacrifices zoom and control.
• Macro: HX5 supports close focusing at 5cm for fine detail shots.
• Night/Astro: HX5’s low-light noise handling gives it an edge, albeit limited by small sensor size on both.
• Video: HX5’s HD 1080p at 60fps is a major plus over W810’s 720p.
• Travel: W810 best for lightweight carry, HX5 better for versatile shooting.
• Professional Work: Neither suited for professional workflows lacking RAW and robustness but HX5 offers better creative control.

Summing It Up: Which Sony Compact Fits Your Needs?

Choosing between the Sony HX5 and Sony W810 depends on your priorities and budget. Here’s a distilled guide to help:

Go for the Sony HX5 if:

• You value image quality, especially in mixed or low light.
• You want a long zoom range (10x) and some manual control options.
• You need decent Full HD video capture.
• You shoot portraits, landscapes, or action that require faster burst rates.
• You prefer a more ergonomic grip and better build.

Consider the Sony W810 if:

• Ultra compact size and extreme portability are your top priorities.
• Your budget is tight, and you want a simple, straightforward point-and-shoot.
• You like the idea of higher resolution images for casual use and cropping flexibility.
• Video and manual exposure are less important.
• You mainly shoot outdoors in good light and want easy sharing.

Final Expert Tips Before You Buy

• Test both cameras in your typical shooting scenarios if possible; personal handling is key.
• Don’t underestimate accessory needs - invest in a good memory card and pouch, especially for the HX5.
• Understand small sensor limitations on image quality: both cameras will struggle with noise above ISO 800. Use them within their strengths.
• For more creative versatility, consider cameras with RAW shooting and better lens systems down the road.

Both models are solid entry points into compact Sony Cyber-shot options, reflecting different eras and user expectations. We hope this comprehensive comparison empowers you to select the camera that best complements your creative ambitions.

Happy shooting! Explore your photographic vision with confidence as you find the perfect compact companion on your journey.

End of Article