Olympus E-1 vs Sony A580: A Comprehensive Camera Comparison for Serious Photographers

Selecting the right camera can feel overwhelming given the diverse options available. Today, we’re diving deep into two distinct DSLRs - Olympus E-1 and Sony Alpha DSLR-A580 - to help you understand their real-world performance, technical merits, and which photographic needs each fulfills best.

These two cameras come from very different eras and design philosophies: the Olympus E-1, launched in late 2003, was Olympus’s first professional DSLR designed for the Four Thirds system, while the Sony A580, introduced in 2011, aimed at entry-level DSLR users looking for solid performance and video capabilities. Despite the generational gap, both offer unique merits worth understanding, especially if your photographic journey spans from vintage precision to digital versatility.

Let’s explore their specs, ergonomics, image quality, and how they perform for various photography genres and workflows.

Getting to Know the Cameras: Size, Design, and Ergonomics

Before we dive into pixels and autofocus points, the camera’s physical handling is foundational to your creative experience. How a camera feels in your hands influences your shooting comfort during extended sessions and your efficiency in the field.

Physical Dimensions and Handling

The Olympus E-1 is a large, professional-grade DSLR with a robust magnesium alloy body designed to endure demanding conditions. It weighs approximately 735 grams and measures 141 x 104 x 81 mm. In contrast, the Sony A580 is comparatively compact and lighter, weighing 599 grams with dimensions around 137 x 104 x 84 mm. Both have a somewhat boxy SLR silhouette, but the A580 is designed with entry-level photographers in mind, favoring portability.

Control Layout and Design

Olympus focused heavily on durability and professional control layout. The E-1 features an optical pentaprism viewfinder with 100% frame coverage and a traditional fixed 1.8-inch screen. Its buttons and dials cater to manual control enthusiasts, though the screen resolution is minimal by modern standards - just 134k pixels - limiting live image checks.

Sony’s A580 upgrades ergonomics in several ways. The 3-inch tilting LCD with a sharp 922k resolution offers flexibility for framing in awkward positions and better menu navigation. Its optical pentamirror viewfinder provides roughly 95% coverage, slightly less than Olympus, but sufficient for most compositions. Both cameras lack touchscreen capability. The A580 includes a more versatile button system, including a dedicated AF mode dial and convenient playback controls.

Ultimately, if you value rugged build and a classic DSLR feel, the Olympus E-1 delivers. If you prefer a lighter body with a better display for flexible composition, the Sony A580 offers modern ergonomics without sacrificing too much durability.

Sensor Technology, Image Quality and Resolution

How the camera captures light and translates it into images defines your results. Sensor size, resolution, and technology have evolved substantially between these two cameras.

Sensor Size and Type

The Olympus E-1 utilizes a Four Thirds CCD sensor measuring 17.3 x 13 mm with an area of about 225 mm². This sensor, at the time revolutionary for Olympus as the first digital Four Thirds format sensor, offers a crop factor of about 2.1x compared to full-frame.

The Sony A580 features an APS-C CMOS sensor, approximately 23.5 x 15.6 mm (about 367 mm²), almost 63% larger sensor area than the E-1. This sensor is known for better noise handling and higher dynamic range thanks to advances in CMOS technology and BIONZ image processing.

Resolution and Detail

• Olympus E-1: 5 megapixels (max resolution of 2560 x 1920)
• Sony A580: 16 megapixels (max resolution of 4912 x 3264)

Clearly, for detail-rich photography, the Sony A580’s 16 MP sensor outperforms the E-1 by a wide margin. This is crucial for large prints, cropping flexibility, and capturing fine textures.

Image Quality Metrics

DXO Mark scores (where available) confirm:

• The Sony A580 scores strongly with 23.8 bits color depth, 13.3 stops dynamic range, and decent low-light ISO sensitivity.
• The Olympus E-1 has no DXO rating, but early reviews consistently praise its color reproduction and sharpness, though at lower resolution and dynamic range compared to newer sensors.

Native ISO Ranges

• Olympus E-1: ISO 100 to 3200
• Sony A580: ISO 100 to 12800 native, expandable to 25600 (boosted)

The larger sensor and newer sensor architecture of the A580 provide superior high ISO performance, an important advantage for low-light and action photography.

Viewing and User Interface: The Shooting Experience

Shooting is as much about what you see and control as the raw specs.

Viewfinder Quality

• Olympus E-1: Optical pentaprism, 100% coverage, 0.48x magnification
• Sony A580: Optical pentamirror, 95% coverage, 0.53x magnification

The Olympus offers a slightly larger and more accurate viewfinder, beneficial for precise composition. Pentaprisms tend to have brighter viewfinders, while the Sony’s pentamirror design keeps the camera lighter.

LCD Screen

• Olympus E-1: Fixed 1.8” LCD, 134k resolution, no live view
• Sony A580: 3-inch tilting LCD, 922k resolution, supports live view

The Sony A580’s screen is a substantial upgrade. Live view enables more flexible shooting angles and better framing for video or tripod work. The tilting function helps street, macro, or awkward-angle photography.

Your choice depends on your shooting style: traditionalists will accept the smaller viewfinder and screen on the E-1, but most will appreciate the enhanced display and live view on the A580.

Autofocus and Shooting Performance

Precise, quick autofocus can make or break a shoot, especially with dynamic subjects.

Autofocus System

• Olympus E-1: 3 autofocus points, phase-detection with contrast confirmation, no face detection or tracking.
• Sony A580: 15 autofocus points (3 cross-type), advanced hybrid AF combining phase and contrast detection, with face detection and AF tracking supported.

The Sony’s autofocus is vastly superior for action, wildlife, and fast-moving subjects. With 15 points and tracking features, it excels in continuous autofocus modes useful in sports or wildlife photography. The E-1’s AF system is comparatively basic and slow by modern standards, better suited for controlled studio or landscape shots.

Continuous Shooting Speed

• Olympus E-1: 3 frames per second (fps)
• Sony A580: 7 fps

The Sony nearly doubles the burst rate, an advantage for sports photography and capturing fleeting moments.

Versatility Across Photography Genres

Different photography styles demand different camera capabilities. Let’s see how these two perform in real-life use.

Portrait Photography

• E-1: Excellent color rendering for skin tones due to CCD sensor characteristics. The 4:3 aspect ratio offers a unique framing style. Lenses with good aperture ranges on Four Thirds mount help achieve creamy bokeh despite smaller sensor size.
• A580: Higher resolution and superior autofocus with face detection benefit portraits. APS-C sensor offers shallower depth of field, yielding better subject isolation.

Recommendation: For portrait photographers wanting classic rendering and bright colors, the E-1 works well but lacks autofocus sophistication. The A580 is better for capturing sharp, diverse portraits with ease thanks to autofocus and higher resolution.

Landscape Photography

• E-1: Robust weather sealing beneficial outdoors. Its CCD sensor delivers rich color fidelity. 5 MP resolution may limit large print size but offers solid quality.
• A580: Higher dynamic range and resolution yield more detailed and flexible landscape images, though no weather sealing reduces ruggedness.

Recommendation: For the outdoors and demanding weather, Olympus E-1’s sealing is a plus, but the A580’s superior resolution and dynamic range better suit most landscape shooters.

Wildlife Photography

• E-1: Moderate autofocus and slow burst make it challenging for fast animals. Magnification factor of 2.1x effectively doubles reach of telephoto lenses.
• A580: Excellent continuous AF and 7 fps shooting with a 1.5x crop still provide good reach and rapid tracking.

Recommendation: Sony A580 is the stronger candidate for wildlife despite slightly less crop factor, thanks to AF and burst speed.

Sports Photography

• E-1: Older and slower AF/tracking not ideal.
• A580: Robust AF tracking and 7 FPS burst outperform E-1 hands down.

Recommendation: A580 is preferable for sports.

Street Photography

• E-1: Bulky and less discreet; slower AF.
• A580: Smaller, lightweight, silent live view option, and fast focusing better suit street photography.

Recommendation: Sony A580 for street shooters.

Macro Photography

• E-1: No built-in stabilization, but Four Thirds lenses often optically stabilized.
• A580: Sensor-based stabilization helps with hand-held macro shots.

Recommendation: Sony’s in-body image stabilization gives it an edge here.

Night and Astro Photography

• E-1: CCD sensor known for pleasing star rendition, but limited ISO flexibility.
• A580: Higher ISO range and better low-light performance favor night shooting.

Recommendation: Sony A580 overall better for night and astro.

Video Capabilities and Connectivity

The Olympus E-1 predates video recording in DSLRs altogether - no video capabilities exist.

The Sony A580 records Full HD 1080p video at 60 or 29.97 fps, with support for AVCHD and MPEG-4 formats. It has a built-in flash with multiple modes and external flash support.

Additionally, Sony supports Eye-Fi card wireless transfer - though no integrated Wi-Fi or Bluetooth.

This makes the A580 far more versatile for multimedia creators and vloggers.

Build, Durability, and Weather-Sealing

The Olympus E-1 boasts weather sealing, dustproofing, and a rugged magnesium alloy chassis designed for professional field use.

The Sony A580 opts for a plastic and metal build with no environmental sealing. It is lighter but less suited for rough conditions.

Choose Olympus if you shoot in tough environments requiring a weather-sealed body.

Battery Life and Storage

• Olympus E-1 uses Compact Flash Type I/II cards and has no official battery life spec, but generally shorter endurance due to older battery tech.
• Sony A580 supports dual storage: SD/SDHC/SDXC and Memory Stick Pro Duo, enhancing flexibility.
• Sony’s battery life rated at around 1050 shots per charge, effective for extended shoots.

Sony’s modern battery system and dual card slots make it more convenient for long days.

Lens Compatibility and Ecosystem

• Olympus E-1 uses Four Thirds mount, with about 45 lenses available, including excellent primes and professional-grade zooms. However, the Four Thirds system has since evolved into Micro Four Thirds.
• Sony A580 uses the Sony/Minolta Alpha (A-mount) with around 143 lenses available, providing a vast selection from wide-angle to telephoto.

Sony’s ecosystem is wider, though original Minolta legacy lenses are older. Olympus lenses tend to be compact and optically sharp.

Price-to-Performance and Value Assessment

• Olympus E-1 launched at around $1700; now primarily found used at lower prices.
• Sony A580 originally retailed around $850 and remains a budget-friendly option on the used market.

For photographers on a budget, the Sony A580 offers much better specifications and performance for its price.

Summary of Key Specifications

Hands-on Evaluation through Multiple Photographic Lenses

Olympus E 1 screen back Sony A580 front Sony A580 screen back

Real-world tests showed:

• Olympus E-1’s colors especially in controlled studio portraits and landscapes were pleasing but required well-lit scenes to maximize quality.
• The Sony A580’s higher resolution and better AF responded well during low-light street photography and fast action sequences.
• Video recordings on A580 were crisp and usable for casual projects.
• Olympus’s weather sealing comforted landscape photographers working outdoors in varying conditions.

Performance Ratings Overview

Here we summarize our hands-on performance metrics and industry benchmarks:

• Sony A580 outperforms in:

  • Autofocus speed and tracking
  • Image detail and ISO performance
  • Video capability
  • User interface responsiveness

• Olympus E-1 excels in:

  • Build ruggedness and weather resistance
  • Color rendition for controlled conditions
  • Optical viewfinder quality

Genre-Specific Suitability at a Glance

Final Takeaways: Which Camera is Right for You?

Choose the Olympus E-1 if:

• You prioritize rugged weather-sealed body, critical for demanding outdoor use
• You appreciate classic CCD color rendering for studio portraits and landscapes
• You shoot mostly still subjects with manual control
• You don’t need video or fast autofocus
• You prefer the Four Thirds lens mount ecosystem and smaller lenses
• You enjoy a traditional DSLR shooting experience with optical excellence

Choose the Sony A580 if:

• You want higher-resolution images and more versatile sensor performance
• You shoot fast action, wildlife, sports with superior autofocus and 7 fps burst
• You want Full HD video alongside stills
• You prefer a modern user interface with tilting screen and live view
• You value in-body image stabilization for handheld work
• You want a lighter, more compact DSLR for travel and street
• You need dual card slots and longer battery life to support longer shooting sessions
• You seek better value for money on the used market

Getting Started and Further Exploration

Both cameras, despite their age, serve as excellent tools depending on your artistic vision and shooting conditions. I encourage you to:

• Visit a camera store and handle both bodies to see which feels better in your hands.
• Experiment with lenses from their respective mounts to test real-life image quality and versatility.
• Check out sample galleries online for each camera to assess their image output for your preferred genres.
• Consider your workflow needs, especially if video or wireless connectivity are important.
• Explore compatible accessories like external flashes, tripods, and battery grips designed around each system.

Photography is a journey, and selecting a camera is just the first step toward your creative expression. Whether you lean towards the Olympus E-1’s classic robustness or the Sony A580’s modern flexibility, both will serve to build your skills and portfolio.

Thank you for joining us on this in-depth comparison. Happy shooting - and may your next camera help capture your vision beautifully!

gallery

Olympus E 1 screen back Sony A580 front Sony A580 screen back