Panasonic Lumix S1H vs. Pentax K-5 IIs: A Deep Dive into Two Worlds of Photography

When it comes to choosing a camera, enthusiasts and professionals face a dizzying array of options - from modern mirrorless marvels to revered DSLRs. Today, I’d like to take you on a thorough comparative journey of two distinct cameras that represent different generations and philosophies of photography gear: the still-impressive Panasonic Lumix S1H (a full-frame professional mirrorless powerhouse released in 2019) versus the beloved Pentax K-5 IIs (an APS-C advanced DSLR that won hearts back in 2013). Each has its own merits, quirks, and target audience.

Let me guide you through their physical design, innards, shooting capabilities, and overall value. By the end, you’ll have a clear understanding of which one suits your photography ambitions, style, and budget.

Size and Ergonomics: Handling the Panasonic S1H vs. Pentax K-5 IIs

The very first thing you notice picking these two cameras up is how dramatically different they feel in the hand. The Panasonic Lumix S1H is a substantial beast designed for a solid grip and extended professional use, while the Pentax K-5 IIs is a compact workhorse that’s easier to carry but still quite capable.

Looking at the Panasonic S1H’s dimensions (151 x 114 x 110 mm) and weight (~1052 g), it’s evident Panasonic built this camera for reliability and stability - especially when using large full-frame lenses or engaging in video work. On the other hand, the Pentax K-5 IIs (131 x 97 x 73 mm, 760 g) feels lighter and smaller in comparison, something street photographers or travelers might appreciate. The DSLR design, though heavier than some mirrorless rivals of its era, offers a confident grip and solid build.

Ergonomically, both cameras emphasize different strengths. The S1H features illuminated buttons, a fully articulated 3.2-inch touchscreen, and a high-resolution electronic viewfinder, leaning into modern user experience expectations. Pentax sticks to a fixed, non-touch 3-inch LCD and optical pentaprism viewfinder, which many photographers still prefer for its natural clarity and lag-free viewing.

The top control layouts on both cameras reinforce their design ethos - let’s take a closer look.

A Closer Look from Above: Control Layouts That Matter

The Panasonic S1H flaunts a professional-grade control panel designed for speedy access to shooting modes, focus adjustments, and exposure compensation. The physical dials are large, satisfying, and customizable - precisely the kind of responsive layout you want under hectic shooting conditions.

By contrast, the Pentax K-5 IIs offers the classic DSLR control scheme. While it lacks the illuminated buttons or touchscreen interface of the S1H, it provides direct tactile dials for ISO, shutter speed, and exposure, with a straightforward pentaprism optical viewfinder offering 100% coverage at 0.61x magnification. It's a layout forged in practicality - no surprises, just familiar controls that photographers have used for decades.

Both cameras cater to photographers who prefer manual exposure control and quick adjustment, but the S1H’s layout leans towards the demands of video professionals and modern hybrid shooters.

The Heart of the Matter: Sensor Technology and Image Quality

Dive deeper, and the sensor is the true storyteller here. Panasonic’s S1H boasts a full-frame CMOS sensor measuring 35.6 x 23.8 mm, offering 24 megapixels with an anti-aliasing filter - a balance of resolution and noise control that excels in both stills and high-end video production.

The Pentax K-5 IIs uses a smaller APS-C CMOS sensor at 23.7 x 15.7 mm with a 16-megapixel resolution but notably, it removes the anti-aliasing filter. This absence provides notably sharper images with finer detail at the cost of some moiré artifacts when shooting complex patterns.

I measured both under controlled studio conditions and outdoor shoots. The full-frame sensor of the S1H naturally collected more light, producing smoother high-ISO images, better dynamic range, and richer color depth - no surprises there. The Pentax’s APS-C sensor, while smaller and older, still delivers excellent image quality for its class, with sharpness that many portrait and landscape photographers seek.

To help visualize their sensor differences and potential image quality impact, here’s the size comparison:

The S1H’s native ISO range (100 to 51200, expandable to 50–204800) allows for highly flexible shooting in diverse lighting - from bright daylight to low-lit environments without significant noise penalty. Pentax’s ISO tops at 12800 (boosted to 51200), which was outstanding when it debuted but shows its age compared to modern sensors.

Versatility in Display and Interface: Touchscreen vs. Traditional LCDs

Let’s talk about interface responsiveness and usability during shoots. The Panasonic S1H offers a high-resolution, fully articulated 3.2-inch touchscreen LCD supporting touch-focus, menu navigation, and playback gestures. For videographers especially, the articulating screen grants creative shooting angles, including selfie modes for vlogging or monitoring exposure precisely.

Not to be overshadowed, the Pentax K-5 IIs utilizes a fixed 3-inch TFT LCD with a 921k-dot resolution. It’s bright and clear but lacks touchscreen capability or physical articulation. For many photographers, especially DSLRs’ traditional members, this isn’t a dealbreaker - they prefer using the optical viewfinder more often, which the K-5 IIs delivers with 100% coverage.

Here’s a visual on their rear screen differences:

Personal preference plays a big role here. I appreciate the S1H’s touchscreen for quick AF selection and confirmation during video shoots - very handy - while I still admire the simplicity and reliability of the Pentax’s solid fixed panel for consistent viewing.

Who Wins in the Autofocus Arena?

Modern autofocus (AF) performance often makes or breaks a modern camera’s usability, especially for fast-moving subjects. Here, the Panasonic S1H benefits from a hybrid contrast-detection-based AF system with face-detection and eye-detection capabilities across 225 focus points, providing excellent tracking for both photo and video.

Meanwhile, the Pentax K-5 IIs relies on an older 11-point phase-detection AF system with 9 cross-type points - still competent but naturally less advanced in tracking specifics and subject recognition.

In practical tests (low light, erratic movement, and portrait scenarios), the S1H’s continuous AF and eye-detection yielded far more reliable sharpness, especially when shooting video or fast action. The Pentax performed well for static subjects or moderately paced shots, but would struggle with aggressive subject tracking demands.

If you primarily shoot wildlife, sports, or fast-paced street photography, you’ll feel the S1H’s AF advantage firsthand. However, for calm portraiture or landscape work where manual focus and live view AF suffice, the K-5 IIs remains solid.

Shutter Performance, Frame Rates, and Burst Shooting

Need speed? The S1H offers a maximum shutter speed of 1/8000s and a silent electronic shutter as well, with a burst rate of 9 frames per second (fps). The Pentax K-5 IIs lags slightly behind at 7 fps and lacks an electronic shutter option, sticking to mechanical only.

In my experience shooting sports and wildlife, that slight edge on burst mode can be significant. The S1H’s silent shutter option is also a boon for discreet shooting scenarios like weddings or theater. The Pentax’s shutter is notably sturdy, however, with a proven durability record - something pro photographers trust implicitly.

Let’s Talk Video: The Panasonic S1H Runs the Show

If video is on your radar, the Panasonic S1H is a beast designed with videographers in mind. It captures 6K video at 24p (5952 x 3988 pixels) with 10-bit 4:2:2 color internally, using advanced codecs like H.265 and H.264. It supports V-Log recording for great dynamic range retention, alongside professional audio input options (microphone and headphone ports) and in-body 5-axis image stabilization.

Compare this to the Pentax K-5 IIs, which maxes out at 1080p HD video at 25fps, encoded as Motion JPEG - a far cry from current video standards. While it does have a microphone input, it lacks advanced video features you’d expect on a hybrid system.

The S1H perfectly suits creators who juggle high-res photography with professional video workflows, while the K-5 IIs is strictly a still photographer’s machine with limited video utility.

Weather Sealing and Durability: Shooting Anywhere Confidence

Both cameras offer environmental sealing, letting you shoot in challenging conditions with confidence. While not fully waterproof or shockproof, they can withstand dust and moisture effectively.

The Pentax lives up to the brand’s reputation for ruggedness with a solid magnesium alloy body and sealing around buttons and dials. The Panasonic also uses a robust build tailored for professional fieldwork, with added attention to heat management for video recording.

If durability under adverse conditions is a must for your work (landscape, wildlife, adventure), both models can serve you well, but the S1H edges out on professional-grade build quality due to its recent design.

Lens Ecosystem: Leica L Mount vs. Pentax KAF2 Mount

Lens choice often dictates camera longevity, so here’s the lowdown.

The Panasonic Lumix S1H uses the Leica L mount, which is part of the L-Mount Alliance including Panasonic, Leica, and Sigma. This provides access to a rapidly expanding lineup of native full-frame lenses, including high-end primes, zooms, and specialty optics. The availability of 30 native lenses and third-party options gives you strong versatility for portrait, landscape, wildlife, and macro photography.

On the other hand, the Pentax K-5 IIs sports the venerable Pentax KAF2 mount, supporting more than 150 lenses, a huge legacy ecosystem. Many vintage lenses still perform exceptionally on this body, making it attractive for photographers who treasure classic glass or want budget-friendly options.

If you value contemporary optics with cutting-edge autofocus, the Panasonic wins. If you treasure legacy lenses and vast compatibility with mechanical lenses, Pentax is unbeatable.

Battery Life and Storage Solutions: Powering Your Passion

The Pentax K-5 IIs surprises with its 980-shot battery life rating - a strong point of DSLRs in general - which translates well into real shooting days without constant recharge. The S1H, being a mirrorless model with a bright EVF and extensive video usage, manages around 400 shots per charge, which is in line with other mirrorless full-frame bodies but requires you to carry spare batteries if you shoot all day.

Storage-wise, the S1H features dual UHS-II SD card slots for simultaneous or relay recording, crucial when shooting pro video or continuous burst stills. The Pentax offers a single slot supporting SD/SDHC/SDXC cards, suitable for less demanding workflows.

You’ll want to plan battery and media choices based on your shooting volume and tendency to shoot video.

Connectivity and Workflow Integration: Wireless vs. Wired

The Panasonic S1H’s built-in Wi-Fi and Bluetooth allow for fast, wireless transfer of files and remote camera control - essential tools in fast-paced professional environments. HDMI and USB-C outputs facilitate high-quality video monitoring and tethered shooting.

The Pentax K-5 IIs lacks wireless connectivity but offers USB 2.0 and HDMI outputs. For some, the absence of Wi-Fi is a dealbreaker; for others, a wired workflow remains preferable for reliability and security.

Pricing and Value: Professional Investment vs. Affordability

At a steep price tag of around $4000 (body only), the Panasonic S1H demands you be serious about video and professional full-frame image quality. It’s a significant investment but delivers capabilities aspiring and pro filmmakers crave.

Meanwhile, the Pentax K-5 IIs can be found used for under $800, offering tremendous value for APS-C enthusiasts focused mainly on still photography.

Performance Scores: Objective Ratings Summarized

To sum up their performance based on standardized testing and real-world usage:

As expected, the S1H scores impressively across image quality, video, autofocus, and build. The Pentax K-5 IIs holds its own especially in image sharpness (due to no AA filter) and battery life but falls behind in sensor resolution and video prowess.

Specialty Genres: How They Excel Across Photography Types

Finally, let’s examine these cameras through the lens of specific photography disciplines:

• Portraiture: S1H’s eye-detection AF and full-frame sensor create splendid skin tones and creamy bokeh. The Pentax yields sharp portraits but smaller sensor limits depth of field control.
• Landscape: Both have weather sealing, but S1H’s dynamic range and 24 MP resolution provide more flexibility in post. Pentax’s APS-C is excellent for enthusiasts.
• Wildlife: Faster AF and burst rate of S1H make it superior. Pentax’s 7fps is decent but limited AF points restrict tracking.
• Sports: S1H dominant for continuous shooting and autofocus. Pentax acceptable for amateur sports.
• Street: Pentax’s smaller size and discreet operation give it a slight edge; S1H is bulkier but silent shutter is nice.
• Macro: Lens availability favors Pentax’s legacy glass, but Panasonic’s stabilization and focus stacking is appealing.
• Night/Astro: Full-frame sensor gives S1H an edge here with lower noise.
• Video: No contest. Panasonic S1H is a professional video machine.
• Travel: Pentax’s smaller size and battery life are travel-friendly; S1H packs professional features for serious trips.
• Pro Work: S1H built for professional reliability, file formats, and workflow integration; Pentax suitable for serious amateurs.

Wrap-Up: Which Camera Is Right for You?

In essence, you’re looking at two very different cameras designed for different ecosystems and photo-video priorities. Here’s how I’d break it down:

• If you’re serious about professional hybrid shooting - high-end video combined with full-frame stills - and willing to invest in a robust system, the Panasonic Lumix S1H is a winner. It offers unmatched video features, modern AF, excellent image quality, and professional ergonomics.

• If you’re an enthusiast photographer focused primarily on still photography, especially with a fondness for classic optics, robust DSLR handling, and a budget-friendly approach, the Pentax K-5 IIs remains a formidable choice. It delivers sharp images, excellent battery life, and a tactile experience many purists love.

To see how they fare in real-world photography, here are sample images from both cameras - notice the differences in dynamic range, color rendition, and depth:

Panasonic S1H front Panasonic S1H screen back Pentax K 5 IIs front Pentax K 5 IIs screen back

I hope this comparison helps you find the camera that fits your unique photographic journey. Remember, the best camera is ultimately the one that inspires you to create consistently.

If you want a quick reference guide for your decision, here’s a handy snapshot scorecard.

Thanks for joining me on this deep dive. Feel free to ask any questions or share your experiences with these cameras!

End of Article