Panasonic Lumix DMC-S1 vs Sony Cyber-shot DSC-HX80: A Deep Dive into Compact Cameras for Your Photography Journey

Choosing between two compact cameras can be daunting, especially when their specs seem close but their real-world performances diverge. Today, we put the Panasonic Lumix DMC-S1 and the Sony Cyber-shot DSC-HX80 head-to-head. Both appeal to photography enthusiasts looking for pocketable options but come from very different design philosophies and eras of camera technology.

With over 15 years of hands-on experience testing and comparing digital cameras across every photography genre, we’ll guide you through practical insights, critical technical analysis, and value assessments to help you pick the camera that fits your creative ambitions. Whether you're looking to capture breathtaking landscapes, intimate portraits, or grab quick street shots, this comparison will illuminate which model suits your needs best.

First Impressions: Size and Handling Matter More Than You Think

Before diving into sensor sizes or autofocus systems, the physical feel of a camera often shapes your shooting experience. Ergonomics can be the deciding factor for daily use.

Analysis:
The Panasonic S1 is clearly the smaller and lighter of the two. Its slim profile makes it incredibly pocket-friendly, ideal for travel or casual carry. However, it comes at the expense of dedicated controls - there’s no manual exposure mode or shutter priority, which may frustrate advanced users who want quick tactile access to settings.

In contrast, the Sony HX80 is almost twice as heavy and noticeably thicker, partly due to its extensive zoom lens and electronic viewfinder. Its slightly larger build offers more control buttons and a better handhold, which benefits stability, especially at long focal lengths.

Takeaway: If ultra-portability is your priority, the Panasonic wins outright. If you want more grip and manual handling while still maintaining compactness, the Sony is the better fit.

Sensor and Image Quality: The Heart of the Camera

The sensor's size, resolution, and technology heavily influence image detail, dynamic range, and low-light capability.

Technical Insights:
While both cameras share the same sensor size class (1/2.3”), the Sony HX80 incorporates a more modern BSI-CMOS sensor. This sensor design allows light to reach the photodiodes more efficiently than the older CCD sensor in the Panasonic S1, which typically struggles with noise and dynamic range.

The Sony also offers 18MP versus the Panasonic’s 12MP, which means finer detail and better cropping flexibility. The wider ISO range on Panasonic (up to 6400 native) is somewhat negated by inherent sensor noise in CCDs, whereas the Sony's lower native ISO cap is balanced by better noise control thanks to BSI design and XAVC S video processing.

Real-World Impact:
In daylight and well-lit conditions, both cameras produce acceptable JPEG files. The Sony HX80 excels in retaining detail and offering better highlight/shadow balance due to its processor and sensor combination. Low-light images from the Panasonic appear softer with more noise, whereas Sony’s camera handles darkness and indoor shots more cleanly.

Conclusion: If image quality, detail, and low-light performance are paramount, the Sony HX80’s sensor and processor hold a tangible advantage.

Autofocus and Shooting Speed: Capturing the Decisive Moment

Your camera's autofocus (AF) capabilities and shooting speed can mean the difference between nailing a fleeting wildlife shot or missing it entirely.

What We Saw in Testing:
The Panasonic Lumix DMC-S1’s autofocus is basic: purely contrast-based, single-shot focusing without any face detection or tracking. This makes it slow and less reliable for moving subjects. Continuous AF targeting and tracking are not supported, which limits its suitability for action, wildlife, or sports.

Sony’s HX80 shines here, with a well-implemented contrast-detection AF system augmented by face detection and continuous AF modes. It can track moving subjects fairly well in good light. The burst shooting at 10 frames per second is an enthusiast-level feature, allowing you to capture fast action sequences with ease.

User Scenarios:

• If your focus is casual snapshots or static subjects (portraits, landscapes), Panasonic’s AF can work but may feel sluggish.
• For wildlife, sports, or street photographers who anticipate quick moments, Sony’s autofocus system and decisive burst shooting offer clear advantages.

Lens and Zoom: How Much Reach and Versatility Do You Need?

Both cameras feature fixed lenses, but the specifications greatly differ.

Interpretation:
The Panasonic offers a modest 4x optical zoom covering the classic 28–112mm range (equiv. full frame). This is excellent for standard portraits, casual travel snaps, and general usage with decent wide-angle coverage.

Sony’s HX80 offers a massive 30x zoom reaching the telephoto equivalent of 720mm. This superzoom is incredibly versatile for travel and wildlife, letting you frame distant subjects up close without swapping lenses - something not possible on either model.

However, note that the Sony’s extreme telephoto comes with the usual tradeoffs: reduced sharpness at max zoom and narrower apertures, requiring good light or higher ISOs to maintain quality.

Display and Viewfinder: Seeing Your Shot Clearly

Good composition tools matter, especially if you shoot outdoors or in bright environments.

Practical Considerations:
The Panasonic S1’s small, fixed 2.7” screen is modest, has low resolution, and isn’t touchscreen-enabled. This can hinder usability in bright light or when composing at odd angles.

Sony’s HX80 benefits from a higher resolution, larger tilt screen, greatly improving visibility and flexibility for low or high-angle shooting - vital for travel and street photography.

Moreover, the inclusion of an electronic viewfinder on the HX80 is a game-changer for outdoor use. An EVF helps frame shots accurately under sunlight, something the Panasonic lacks entirely.

For the user who:

• Prefers composing with a viewfinder (especially in bright conditions) → Sony HX80
• Wants a quick grab-and-go with a simple screen → Panasonic S1 is adequate

Video Capabilities: Will Your Camera Double as a Vlogging Tool?

Video specs have become a crucial factor - even for photo-centric cameras.

Real-World Testing:
The Panasonic S1’s video offering is extremely limited - HD at only 720p and capped at 30fps. The older Motion JPEG codec is less efficient and not suited for modern editing workflows.

Sony’s HX80 offers solid Full HD video at 60fps with advanced codecs (XAVC S) that deliver cleaner footage at smaller file sizes. Optical stabilization helps smooth handheld shots, and the tilting screen supports selfie shooting, popular with vloggers. That said, the lack of microphone input limits external audio upgrades.

Summary:

• For video enthusiasts and vloggers, Sony’s HX80 is clearly ahead with higher resolution, fps, and better codec support.
• Panasonic’s S1 video is quite basic and unlikely to satisfy users aiming for quality content creation.

Battery Life and Storage: How Long Can You Shoot?

Battery endurance and flexible storage options impact usability during long shoots or travel.

Sony’s edge in battery life means fewer interruptions for recharging on extended outings. Its ability to support two common card types adds versatility, especially for those with accessories or existing memory cards.

Build Quality and Weather Sealing: Ready for Adventure?

Neither Panasonic S1 nor Sony HX80 offers weather sealing or ruggedness features. Both are designed as everyday compacts rather than pro-grade adventure cameras.

Handle with care to avoid dust or moisture damage, and use protective accessories if shooting in challenging environments.

Connectivity and Extras: Sharing and Usability

Sony’s built-in Wi-Fi and NFC make it much easier to transfer photos wirelessly to your smartphone, a useful productivity booster for social sharing or remote control shooting. HDMI output allows external monitoring and playback.

Real-World Performance Examples

Let’s look at sample images from both cameras highlighting their key photographic genres, illustrating sharpness, color rendition, and dynamic range.

Panasonic S1 front Panasonic S1 screen back Sony HX80 front Sony HX80 screen back

Portrait Photography

• Panasonic S1: Skin tones appear natural but softer. Limited depth of field from the f/3.1 max aperture restricts background blur.
• Sony HX80: Slightly crisper detail and good face detection helps nail focus. The lens’s narrower aperture at telephoto end limits bokeh but zoom flexibility allows creative framing.

Landscape Photography

• Panasonic S1: Sharp wide-angle shots with faithful color, but limited resolution constrains large prints.
• Sony HX80: Higher resolution and wide zoom range detail distant landscapes well, though dynamic range is similar.

Wildlife and Sports

• Panasonic’s slow AF and lack of continuous shooting make it unsuitable.
• Sony HX80 autofocus tracking and 10 fps burst rate make it capable for casual wildlife and sports, though not professional sport levels.

In-Depth Performance Ratings

We summarized overall and genre-specific performance considering sensor, AF, ergonomics, and features.

Summing It Up: Who Should Buy Which?

Choose Panasonic Lumix DMC-S1 if:

• You prioritize ultra-compact carry with minimalist design.
• You shoot mostly static subjects and casual photography.
• Image quality requirements are modest and video is secondary.
• Budget is tighter, and you want a pocket-friendly option that's very easy to deploy.

Choose Sony Cyber-shot DSC-HX80 if:

• Versatility matters: long zoom range, manual exposure controls, and decent video capabilities.
• You need fast, reliable autofocus and continuous shooting for action or wildlife shooting.
• You want wireless sharing, tilt-screen flexibility, and an electronic viewfinder.
• You desire better all-around image quality and creative control on a compact platform.

Final Words: Taking Your Next Step

Both cameras reflect distinct eras and target audiences in small-sensor compact photography. The Panasonic Lumix DMC-S1 offers simple, straightforward photography with a pocketable design, fit for beginners or casual users.

Sony’s Cyber-shot DSC-HX80, introduced five years later, packs more advanced technology, making it a well-rounded travel and enthusiast camera with a powerful zoom and modern autofocus.

We highly recommend trying both in hand if possible. Pay attention to handling, zoom feel, and viewfinder comfort since these affect daily use beyond specs.

Whichever you choose, remember that cameras unlock your creative potential when paired with practice and passion. Get started with one of these, then explore lenses, accessories, or eventually larger sensor systems as your eye and skills develop.

Happy shooting!

This detailed comparison reflects over a decade of professional testing experience, technical appraisal, and user-centric evaluation aimed at empowering your photographic choices.

End of article.