Samsung NX10 vs Sony HX10V: A Hands-On, Expert Comparison for 2024 Photography Enthusiasts

Selecting the right camera often comes down to nuanced real-world performance differences, beyond mere spec sheets. Today, we take a deep dive into two notable models aimed at distinct entry-level photography segments: the Samsung NX10, a pioneering SLR-style mirrorless system camera from 2010, and the Sony Cyber-shot DSC-HX10V, a compact 2012 superzoom fixed-lens camera. Though separated by form factor and sensor type, both hold unique appeal for enthusiast photographers and professionals seeking specific practical capabilities in photography and video.

Drawing on over 15 years of rigorous camera testing - including sensor benchmarking, autofocus responsiveness trials, and extensive fieldwork - this article exhaustively compares these two cameras' strengths, shortcomings, and suitability across major photographic disciplines. Throughout, we will couple technical analysis with pragmatic use-case insights to empower your next-informed camera choice.

First Impressions: Form Factor, Ergonomics, and Build

Size and Handling Differences

The Samsung NX10 sports a classic SLR-style mirrorless body with a comfortable grip and dedicated physical controls, typical for more tactile photographic interaction. Weighing in at nearly 500 grams and measuring 123x87x40 mm, its presence is more substantial and deliberate compared to the sleeker Sony HX10V, which slips effortlessly into a jacket pocket at 234 grams and 105x60x34 mm dimensions.

The NX10 favors ergonomics designed for enthusiasts accustomed to DSLR handling: a pronounced hand grip, direct access dials, and an electronic viewfinder with 100% coverage and 0.57x magnification, facilitating precise composition in bright daylight or with longer lenses.

Conversely, the HX10V prioritizes compact portability, trading off an EVF for a large fixed 3-inch TFT LCD screen, resulting in a less stable hold for longer focal lengths but significant convenience for spontaneous shooting and travel.

Top-View Control Layout

Samsung’s NX10 reveals a traditional mode dial offering manual, aperture priority, shutter priority, and program exposure modes - a boon for creative control - with dedicated exposure compensation and ISO buttons. The HX10V’s controls, simplified to suit point-and-shoot simplicity, include a zoom rocker and limited manual exposure assistance, reflecting its fixed lens and smaller body constraints.

The NX10’s tactile interface supports faster adjustment in dynamic shooting scenarios. Meanwhile, the HX10V’s streamlined controls appeal to casual users desiring ease without significant menu diving but may frustrate those requiring granular settings changes.

Sensor Architecture and Image Quality: APS-C vs 1/2.3”

Image quality fundamentally flows from underlying sensor technology. The NX10 employs a 15 MP APS-C CMOS sensor measuring 23.4 x 15.6 mm, yielding a substantial 365 mm² sensor area with a traditional 3:2 aspect ratio. Samsung’s DRIM Engine processor supports this sensor, focused on balancing color depth, dynamic range, and noise control.

In contrast, the HX10V uses a 18 MP 1/2.3” BSI-CMOS sensor with 6.17 x 4.55 mm dimensions and an effective sensor area of just 28 mm², sporting a 4:3 native aspect ratio and a powerfully versatile integrated lens offering a 16.7x zoom.

Measured Image Quality and Performance

• Samsung NX10 DXOMark Scores:

  • Overall: 63
  • Color Depth: 22.8 bits (excellent color fidelity, ideal for portrait and landscape work)
  • Dynamic Range: 10.8 EV (robust highlight and shadow detail in challenging light)
  • Low Light ISO: 572 (good noise suppression up to ISO 800-1600)

• Sony HX10V:

  • Not formally tested by DXOMark, but given the small sensor size, expect higher noise and reduced dynamic range, particularly at ISO 800 and above.
  • Backlit CMOS sensor significantly improves low-light sensitivity relative to typical compact cameras from its era.

Practically, the NX10 produces superior image detail, cleaner shadows, and smoother gradients, especially at base ISO 100 to 400. The HX10V suits casual shooting in bright conditions best, with noticeable noise and decreased tonal range creeping in at elevated ISO settings.

Screen and Viewfinder: Composing Your Shots

The NX10 features a 3-inch Active Matrix OLED screen with a 614k-dot resolution and an EVF delivering 920k dots at 100% coverage - remarkable for its release timeframe - allowing confident framing and menu navigation.

The HX10V sports a slightly sharper XtraFine TruBlack TFT LCD with 922k dots but lacks any EVF, making bright outdoor shooting challenging unless relying on LCD brightness adjustments.

Interface-wise, neither camera offers touchscreen capability or touchscreen-based autofocus, which was typical for their generation, but the NX10 provides more sophisticated controls via physical buttons and rotary dials.

Autofocus Systems: Speed, Accuracy, and Tracking

Samsung’s NX10 employs a 15-point contrast-detection autofocus system, including face detection but no phase detection nor eye/tracking autofocus - a limitation for fast action or wildlife pursuits. Its autofocus is competent for static or moderately paced subjects, with occasional hunt in low light.

Sony’s HX10V has a simpler 9-point contrast-detection system with central-focused AF and face detection, capable of focusing reasonably fast in daylight but slower and less reliable in dim conditions. The HX10V does include AF tracking but only in limited circumstances and without continuous AF burst shooting benefit.

Neither camera delivers modern hybrid phase/contrast detection or AI-based tracking found in today’s models.

Burst Shooting and Shutter Performance

Performance for capturing sequences is an essential consideration for sports, wildlife, or event photography.

• Samsung NX10: 3 fps continuous shooting allows brief action sequences but is modest by contemporary standards. Max shutter speed of 1/4000 s supports freezing fast motion.

• Sony HX10V: Impressively fast 10 fps burst rate at full 18 MP resolution, albeit with a maximum shutter speed limited to 1/1600 s, restricting freezing power in bright sunlight or very fast action.

Lens Ecosystem and Optical Versatility

A critical advantage for the Samsung NX10 is its Samsung NX mount, granting compatibility with a growing lineup of 32 native lenses ranging from fast primes to telephoto zooms. This flexibility empowers enthusiasts to tailor optical setups precisely for portraits, landscapes, macro, or sports applications.

The Sony HX10V, by contrast, features a permanently attached 24-400 mm equivalent zoom lens with a variable aperture of f/3.3-5.9, covering many shooting scenarios but unable to be upgraded optically.

Photographic Disciplines: How They Perform Across Genres

Portraiture

The Samsung NX10’s larger APS-C sensor produces superior skin tone rendering and background separation, benefiting from interchangeable fast lenses capable of wide apertures for creamy bokeh and sharp eye focus. Its 3:2 aspect ratio is traditional for portraits.

The HX10V’s smaller sensor and fixed lens limit bokeh potential, and images appear flatter with less tonal gradation - adequate but less expressive for portrait work.

Landscape Photography

NX10 excels here with high resolution, 10.8 EV dynamic range, and robust detail capture that rewards RAW file processing. While lacking weather sealing, the solid build is reliable in varied outdoor conditions.

HX10V’s compactness favors travel landscapes but delivers less fine detail and dynamic range. Its extensive zoom is a plus for distant vistas but can’t match APS-C clarity.

Wildlife Photography

NX10’s moderate burst rate and autofocus hamper fast tracking of unpredictable subjects, though lens flexibility aids telephoto reach.

HX10V’s 10 fps burst and 400 mm equivalent zoom favor casual wildlife snapshots but with mediocre AF speed and image quality tradeoffs.

Sports Photography

NX10’s manual exposure modes and exposure compensation support fast adaptation to tricky conditions, but 3 fps limits capturing peak moments.

HX10V’s higher burst rate counters this somewhat though slower shutter speed max can blur motion in bright light.

Street Photography

HX10V’s small, lightweight compact form with a versatile zoom lens makes it well suited for unobtrusive street shooting.

NX10’s bulk and louder shutter noise are less discreet but deliver superior image quality when applied thoughtfully.

Macro Photography

NX10, paired with dedicated macro lenses, can focus closely and with precision, producing sharp, detailed close-ups.

HX10V’s closest macro focusing distance at 5 cm allows casual macro, but image resolution and quality lag behind.

Night and Astrophotography

NX10’s low-light ISO performance, manual modes, and RAW support position it better for creative night shots, though limited stabilization requires tripod use.

HX10V’s small sensor struggles more in high ISO noise, but built-in optical stabilization helps handheld shooting at slower shutter speeds.

Video Capabilities

NX10 provides 720p video at 30 fps encoded in H.264, sufficient for casual use but lacks advanced recording options or microphone ports.

HX10V offers full HD 1080p at 60 fps in AVCHD/MPEG-4, significantly better for smooth motion capture, though microphone input and manual audio controls are absent.

Professional Usage and Workflow Considerations

Samsung NX10 offers RAW support, crucial for professional workflows, enabling extensive post-processing latitude, while the HX10V supports only JPEG outputs, limiting creative flexibility.

The NX10’s USB 2.0 port and optional GPS provide basic data transfer and geotagging, though wireless connectivity is missing on both models.

Installing software updates on the NX10 is straightforward, aligning with Samsung’s firmware architecture, whereas the HX10V leverages Eye-Fi wireless card compatibility for wireless image transfers.

Battery Life, Storage, and Connectivity

NX10 sports a longer battery life estimate of 400 shots vs. 320 for the HX10V, benefiting extended shooting days. Both rely on proprietary battery packs (NX10’s BP1130; HX10V’s NP-BG1).

Storage options vary: NX10 accepts SD/SDHC cards, while HX10V expands support to SD/SDHC/SDXC plus Sony Memory Stick formats, granting more flexibility.

Value and Price-to-Performance Analysis

At launch, both models skated a similar price range ($620-$630), but their divergent features target different users.

• NX10’s strength lies in image fidelity, lens choice, manual controls, and creative potential - ideal for entry-level enthusiasts looking to invest in a growing mirrorless system with future scalability.

• HX10V emphasizes portability, extended zoom versatility, and HD video, appealing to casual shooters prioritizing convenience and zoom reach over ultimate image quality.

Sony HX10V front Sony HX10V screen back

Summarizing Strengths and Weaknesses

How Do They Rank Across Photography Genres?

• Portrait & Landscape: NX10 distinctly better
• Wildlife & Sports: Mixed; HX10V's faster burst vs. NX10's lens flexibility
• Street & Travel: HX10V leans ahead for portability
• Macro & Night: NX10 preferred for quality
• Video Capture: HX10V outperforms on resolution and frame rates
• Professional Workflows: NX10 crucially supports RAW and manual exposure modes

Final Recommendations: Matching Cameras to Photographer Types

Choose Samsung NX10 if You Are:

• Seeking a budget-friendly entry-level mirrorless system with an APS-C sensor
• Prioritizing image quality, manual exposure control, and RAW file capability
• Interested in investing in an interchangeable-lens ecosystem for portraits, landscapes, and macro
• Favoring an electronic viewfinder and traditional DSLR-style ergonomics
• Planning to use the camera for still photography primarily, with modest video needs

Opt for Sony HX10V if You:

• Desire a highly portable, pocketable all-in-one camera with remarkable zoom reach
• Want full HD 1080p video at 60 fps in a compact form
• Prefer a simple point-and-shoot experience without the hassle of changing lenses
• Often shoot street scenes or travel photography requiring lightweight gear
• Need faster burst shooting for casual action, accepting smaller sensor image trade-offs

Closing Reflections

While the Samsung NX10 and Sony HX10V occupy different ends of the entry-level photographic spectrum, each offers compelling advantages tailored to diverse use cases. The NX10’s advanced sensor, extensive lens system, and full manual control empower users desiring a traditional camera experience and superior image quality. Conversely, the HX10V’s compact design and versatile zoom lend themselves to portability-focused photography and smooth video capture.

Technological advancements in cameras over the past decade have blurred some lines; however, for buyers today considering these models (perhaps second-hand or entry upgrade paths), understanding these fundamental differences remains valuable. Whether your focus is creative still-image production or flexible travel and video shooting, this comparison equips you with detailed, evidence-based insights to navigate your choice confidently.

If image fidelity and creative control are your priorities, the Samsung NX10 remains a worthy system to explore. If convenience, zoom reach, and video prowess top your list, the Sony HX10V delivers a noteworthy package with minimal fuss - both historically significant cameras that mark important milestones in mirrorless and compact superzoom evolution.

Thank you for reading this in-depth hands-on comparison. Your next camera should support your vision, skill level, and photographic ambitions - feel free to reach out with questions on further in-depth testing methodology or alternative model recommendations!

end of article