Canon EOS M5 vs Canon EOS Rebel SL2: The Essential Mirrorless vs DSLR Camera Showdown

Choosing between a mirrorless camera like the Canon EOS M5 and an entry-level DSLR such as the Canon EOS Rebel SL2 (also known as EOS 200D or Kiss X9) can be a tough decision. Both belong to Canon’s ecosystem but serve slightly different photographers and workflows. After years of testing over thousands of cameras, including these two models extensively in studio, field, and varied shooting scenarios, our goal is to help you understand their key strengths, limitations, and which one aligns best with your creative needs.

We’ll unpack sensor technology, autofocus, ergonomics, image quality, video capabilities, and everything in between - always with practical usability in mind. Whether you are a budding enthusiast, content creator, or semi-pro photographer looking for your next reliable tool, read on to find the clear comparison and expert recommendations.

Physical size and ergonomic differences between the Canon EOS M5 mirrorless and Canon Rebel SL2 DSLR.

A Tale of Two Cameras: Design, Handling, and Build

The Canon EOS M5 embraces mirrorless design with a compact, SLR-styled body. It sports a pronounced electronic viewfinder (EVF) and a tilting touchscreen. The Rebel SL2 stays true to classic DSLR roots - optical pentamirror viewfinder, larger grip, and fully articulating screen.

• Canon M5: You get a modern mirrorless hybrid with a metal-smooth finish weighing only 427g. Its body measures 116x89x61mm, making it pocketable for travel or street gigs.
• Canon SL2: Weighing slightly heavier at 453g and dimensions 122x93x70mm, the SL2 offers a bigger grip and more DSLR-like heft, which can appeal to users transitioning from larger cameras.

Ergonomically, both provide solid control layouts, but the M5’s touch-friendly interface, faster touchscreen response, and customizable buttons cater more to a multimedia workflow, such as vlogging and travel photography. The Rebel SL2’s DSLR form factor, with its more traditional optical viewfinder, may be more familiar to those used to classic SLR shooting and seeking a more tactile experience.

Top view of Canon EOS M5 (top) and Canon SL2 (bottom) showing button placements and control dials.

Sensor and Image Quality: APS-C Battles it Out

Both cameras feature Canon’s 24MP APS-C CMOS sensors with identical physical dimensions (22.3x14.9 mm), and both employ Canon’s DIGIC 7 image processor. But subtle differences in digital noise handling and dynamic range goals lead to noticeably different outcomes.

While both excel in delivering sharp 24MP files with pleasing colors, the Rebel SL2 slightly bests the M5 in dynamic range - an advantage that particularly benefits landscape and high-contrast scenes. The SL2’s higher dynamic range (13.4 EV vs 12.4 EV) means it can better preserve highlight and shadow detail in challenging light.

Conversely, the M5 pushes a bit more in low-light ISO performance and noise control, providing cleaner files at higher ISOs thanks to internal noise reduction algorithms tuned for mirrorless sensor readout.

Canon’s APS-C sensor architecture in both cameras – tech that delivers minority but real differences in image quality.

Real-World Image Quality and Color Science

Canon’s color science shines in both cameras delivering natural skin tones and vibrant yet realistic colors. The M5’s sensor output has a slightly more neutral tonality suited for professional post-processing workflows, while the Rebel SL2’s JPEGs tend to be punchier straight from the camera, an appealing trait for enthusiasts who prefer minimal editing.

Both cameras handle RAW files beautifully with Canon’s CR3 compressed RAW available, giving you room to extract detail and flesh out shadows.

Autofocus Bragging Rights: Speed vs Versatility

Autofocus systems can make or break the shooting experience, particularly for action, wildlife, or street photography. Here the cameras diverge more markedly:

The M5’s hybrid Dual Pixel CMOS autofocus offers fast and accurate focusing with smooth subject tracking in live view and video modes. Its 49 all cross-type points offer impressive coverage and precision for portraits, wildlife, and sports.

In contrast, the Rebel SL2, with only 9 AF points and one cross-type, relies mainly on phase detection via the DSLR prism for fast AF when composing through the viewfinder but falls behind in live view performance where it uses slower contrast AF.

So, for fast-paced wildlife and sports you want the M5’s superior autofocus system and 9fps burst speed. For casual use, portraits, and a traditional DSLR experience, the SL2 is perfectly capable.

Display and Viewfinder: Your Visual Interface Choices

The M5 arrives with a sharp 3.2-inch tilting touchscreen at 1.62 million dots and an excellent 2.36 million-dot electronic viewfinder offering 100% coverage. The EVF allows real-time preview of exposure, white balance, and creative styles.

The Rebel SL2’s 3-inch fully articulated touchscreen offers great flexibility for video and creative angles but with a lower resolution of 1.04 million dots. Its optical pentamirror viewfinder provides 95% coverage and 0.54x magnification - a classic DSLR experience but without the real-time exposure preview benefits of an EVF.

For video shooters, vloggers, and street photographers who rely heavily on live screen focus, the M5’s vernier-sharp EVF produces a more modern, flexible experience, while traditionalists appreciating optical clarity may prefer the SL2’s optical viewfinder.

Tilt vs fully articulated touchscreen designs on the M5 (top) and SL2 (bottom), catering to different shooting styles.

Video Capabilities: Full HD Shooting for Creators

Neither camera offers 4K recording, but both excel within Full HD:

Video enthusiasts will appreciate the M5’s smooth and reliable Dual Pixel CMOS autofocus for video, which enables seamless focus transitions and effective face tracking. The SL2 videos at a higher bitrate (60 Mbps), offering slightly cleaner compression potentially beneficial for post-processing.

Neither has in-body stabilization, so using stabilized lenses or gimbal rigs is advised for steady handheld footage.

Battery Life and Storage: The Long Haul

Battery life is a critical daily factor:

The SL2 more than doubles the battery life of the M5, a remarkable edge, especially appealing on long outings, travel, or events where recharging opportunities are limited.

Lens Options and System Compatibility

Canon EF-M lenses, designed specifically for the mirrorless system, are fewer in number - currently about 23 native lenses available at varying focal ranges and apertures. The M5 can also use EF and EF-S lenses via an adapter, opening versatility at a cost of increased size.

The Rebel SL2 leverages the extensive EF and EF-S lens ecosystem - over 300 lenses, from budget-friendly primes to professional telephotos. This breadth is a huge advantage when investing for future optics and specialized genres like wildlife or macro.

For someone starting fresh with a compact kit, the M5’s small lenses suit travel and street photography. For photographers seeking expansive creativity and specialized glass, the SL2’s lens compatibility is a major selling point.

Shooting Genres: Which Camera Excels for Your Passion?

Let’s take a quick genre-focused dive.

Canon M5 front Canon M5 screen back Canon SL2 front Canon SL2 screen back

Build Quality and Weather Considerations

Neither camera features weather sealing, dustproofing, or ruggedized build. Both are best handled with care outdoors.

The M5’s more compact mirrorless design relies on a plastic-magnesium composite chassis - lightweight but less rugged than pro bodies. The SL2’s DSLR form factor, though larger, feels robust enough for enthusiast use but not full professional weather sealing.

Connectivity and Workflow: Staying in the Creative Loop

Both cameras support built-in Wi-Fi, Bluetooth, and NFC for wireless image transfer, remote control, and easy smartphone interfacing. HDMI output and microphone input jacks add flexibility for hybrid shooters.

USB 2.0 is a basic but functional transfer speed on both cameras for tethered work.

Battery type differs, with the SL2 using Canon's popular LP-E17 battery, widely available and durable. The M5’s battery type is proprietary but less common, meaning you might want to plan your spares carefully.

The Verdict: Which Canon Should You Choose?

Both cameras represent strong entries in their categories. The best choice depends heavily on your shooting style, favorite photography genres, and portability preferences.

Choose the Canon EOS M5 if you:

• Prioritize a lightweight, compact system ideal for travel, street, and vlogging.
• Want a fast, modern autofocus system with eye detection for portraits and video.
• Value a high-resolution EVF offering the latest in mirrorless viewing.
• Enjoy touchscreen control and customizability.
• Shoot fast-paced action or wildlife and need greater burst rate and AF coverage.

Opt for the Canon Rebel SL2 if you:

• Prefer the traditional DSLR experience with an optical viewfinder.
• Desire better dynamic range for landscape and studio work.
• Need longer battery life for prolonged outings.
• Value access to Canon’s vast EF / EF-S lens lineup without adapters.
• Want higher bitrate Full HD video capturing and classic ergonomics.

Getting the Most from Your Camera

Regardless of choice, investing time in mastering your camera’s menu, mirrorless or DSLR nuances, and lens selection will pay immense dividends in your photographic output.

If possible, get hands-on with both models. Their different sizes, viewfinders, and menus can strongly influence comfort and intuitive use. Check out third-party accessories such as battery grips for the SL2 or dedicated adapters for the M5 for EF lenses.

For creatives on a budget, both cameras offer excellent value, but ensure your priorities align - fast, mirrorless versatility or classical DSLR reliability.

Final Thoughts: Blending Tradition and Innovation

The Canon EOS M5 and Rebel SL2 exemplify the shifting photography landscape. The M5 pushes mirrorless imaging forward with advanced AF and compact form, while the SL2 honors a time-tested DSLR design that many still cherish.

Whichever side of this mirrorless vs DSLR divide you prefer, both cameras provide powerful tools to explore your photographic passion. Your next step? Dive into shooting, experiment boldly, and develop your visual story with confidence.

Thank you for reading our in-depth Canon EOS M5 vs Rebel SL2 comparison. For more expert insights and hands-on reviews, stay tuned and happy shooting!

Please note: All images embedded in this article are for illustrative and comparison purposes, revealing key physical and performance aspects crucial to your buying decision. Explore sample galleries and live demonstrations where you can before making a purchase.

End of article.