Clicky

Nikon S5200 vs Sony HX20V

Portability
95
Imaging
39
Features
26
Overall
33
Nikon Coolpix S5200 front
 
Sony Cyber-shot DSC-HX20V front
Portability
90
Imaging
41
Features
50
Overall
44

Nikon S5200 vs Sony HX20V Key Specs

Nikon S5200
(Full Review)
  • 16MP - 1/2.3" Sensor
  • 3" Fixed Display
  • ISO 125 - 3200
  • 1920 x 1080 video
  • 26-156mm (F) lens
  • 146g - 98 x 58 x 22mm
  • Introduced January 2013
Sony HX20V
(Full Review)
  • 18MP - 1/2.3" Sensor
  • 3" Fixed Screen
  • ISO 100 - 12800
  • Optical Image Stabilization
  • 1920 x 1080 video
  • 25-500mm (F3.2-5.8) lens
  • 254g - 107 x 62 x 35mm
  • Launched July 2012
  • Previous Model is Sony HX10V
  • Updated by Sony HX30V
Apple Innovates by Creating Next-Level Optical Stabilization for iPhone

Nikon Coolpix S5200 vs Sony Cyber-shot HX20V: Compact Camera Showdown for the Discerning Photographer

Choosing the right compact camera can feel deceptively simple: they’re small, easy to carry, and designed for casual shooting. But as anyone who’s tested dozens of compacts will tell you, there’s a rich world hidden behind those petite bodies. Especially when comparing two models like the Nikon Coolpix S5200 and Sony Cyber-shot HX20V, both from the early 2010s but with subtly different design philosophies and ambitions.

Having spent weeks field-testing these cameras side by side across various scenarios, from city streets to scenic landscapes to family gatherings, I’d like to share my detailed observations. My aim is to help photographers - from enthusiasts looking for a daily carry to pros in need of a decent pocketable backup - to match features, strengths, and quirks with their specific needs. Let’s dive in.

Nikon S5200 vs Sony HX20V size comparison

Getting a Feel: Design and Handling

When it comes to compact cameras, size and ergonomics are often prime considerations. Both the Nikon S5200 and Sony HX20V share the same compact category but differ noticeably in presence and feel.

The Nikon S5200 is undeniably slim and light at just 146 grams and measures 98 x 58 x 22 mm. It slips effortlessly into a jacket pocket without creating bulk. Its fixed, modest zoom lens doesn’t protrude too aggressively, keeping its profile sleek and discreet - a benefit if you’re often shooting on the go or in crowded spaces where discretion matters.

The Sony HX20V, by contrast, is chunkier at 254 grams and dimensionally larger (107 x 62 x 35 mm). The difference owes largely to its 20x superzoom lens and more robust battery. Despite this, the Sony's grip is reasonably comfortable, with textured surfaces that give a reassuring hold. The slight heft feels like a compensated trade-off, especially when you consider the potential optical reach and features packed inside.

Looking at the top view layout, Nikon opts for simplicity with minimal buttons, which might appeal to users who prefer an uncluttered interface. Sony has a few more controls, including dedicated zoom rocker and manual focus ring - a nod towards more precise handling and creative control.

Nikon S5200 vs Sony HX20V top view buttons comparison

Both cameras lack electronic viewfinders, relying fully on their LCD screens for composition. This will be a factor if you often shoot in bright sunlight or require composition flexibility.

Sensor and Image Quality: The Core Technical Ingredient

At the heart of any camera is its sensor, dictating the base image quality and flexibility. Both models use a 1/2.3” BSI-CMOS sensor - the industry standard for compact shooters - but with subtle differences worth unpacking.

The Nikon S5200 sports a 16-megapixel sensor, while the Sony HX20V steps up slightly with 18 megapixels, offering a max resolution of 4896 x 3672 px versus Nikon’s 4608 x 3456 px. While this ~12.5% difference in resolution might seem minor, it can impact photographic disciplines where cropping or large prints matter, such as landscape or nature photography.

Sensor physical dimensions are almost identical, around 6.16x4.62 mm for Nikon and 6.17x4.55 mm for Sony. This hints that any boost in resolution on Sony comes from smaller individual pixels, which can impact noise performance.

Neither camera supports RAW shooting, locking users into JPEG compression - a notable limitation for professionals or advanced amateurs accustomed to post-processing flexibility.

Image stabilization is another consideration. Nikon lacks built-in stabilization, a surprising omission for a camera with a telephoto reach. Sony, on the other hand, employs optical image stabilization (OIS), helping in low-light scenarios or at maximum zoom.

Nikon S5200 vs Sony HX20V sensor size comparison

In real-world shooting, this translates to the Sony HX20V generally delivering sharper, cleaner images - particularly when zoomed in or in dimmer lighting - thanks to OIS and a slightly better sensor design and image processor (Sony’s BIONZ).

LCD Screens and User Interface

Both cameras utilize 3-inch fixed LCDs, but the quality and usability diverge significantly.

Nikon’s S5200 LCD has a resolution of 460k dots with a standard TFT panel and anti-reflection coating. This is adequate for framing and reviewing shots indoors or shaded environments.

Sony’s HX20V features a more vibrant 922k dots XtraFine TruBlack TFT LCD, offering brighter, higher-contrast viewing. Outdoors, under sunlight, the Sony screen retained visibility and color fidelity noticeably better than Nikon’s.

Neither provide touchscreen interfaces, which was common given their release years, but both offer straightforward menus with access to essential shooting modes. Canon-esque ease of use may favor Nikon for beginners, while Sony's slightly more complex interface rewards user exploration and creative control.

Nikon S5200 vs Sony HX20V Screen and Viewfinder comparison

Zoom Range and Optical Excellence: Versatility in Framing

Now to the most immediately noticeable operational difference: zoom capability.

The Nikon Coolpix S5200 offers a 6x optical zoom ranging 26-156 mm equivalent. Good for casual shooting, street photography, and medium-telephoto framing. However, it falls short when you want to capture distant wildlife, sports action, or far-off landscapes in detail.

Sony’s HX20V boasts a 20x zoom stretch from 25 to 500 mm equivalent - an impressive reach for a compact. This superzoom range opens creative doors, permitting tight wildlife shots or sports frames from a distance, without necessarily carrying a DSLR and a telephoto lens.

In the field, this lens versatility proved invaluable. The Sony could effortlessly capture birds in flight from afar or detail architectural elements at a distance, while Nikon’s zoom required closer approach - sometimes impractical.

Magnification versatility aside, the Sony also has a macro mode reaching focus distances as little as 1 cm, compared to Nikon’s unspecified macro specs - significant if close-up shots of flowers or textures are in your wishlist.

Autofocus and Shooting Speed: Catching the Moment

The Nikon S5200’s autofocus system is essentially basic contrast detection with no face or eye detection, no manual focus option, and no continuous autofocus mode. This design appears targeted at casual snapshots rather than dynamic action.

Sony’s HX20V counters with a more sophisticated 9-point contrast-detection autofocus with face detection and tracking capabilities. It also provides manual focus, a boon for photographers who want deliberate control or need to tackle tricky lighting situations.

Continuous shooting speeds further echo this divide. Nikon offers no burst mode, making it unsuitable for fast action or fleeting moments. Sony’s HX20V manages a respectable 10 frames per second at full resolution, well-suited to sports, wildlife, or any scenario requiring quick reflexes.

In my experience photographing a busy playground at dusk, the Sony’s AF maintained lock reliably, and the high frame rate minutely increased keeper odds. Nikon occasionally struggled with slower AF and missed focus in low contrast scenes.

Video Performance: What’s in the Moving Picture Department?

Full HD video is supported by both cameras, capped typically at 1920 x 1080 pixels. However, Sony HX20V edges ahead with additional formats (MPEG-4, AVCHD) and 60 fps frame rate, providing smoother motion capture critical for video enthusiasts.

Nikon S5200 offers basic 1080p at 30 fps. Both cameras lack microphone inputs, headphone jacks, or advanced video features, reflecting their positioning as casual shooters.

Optical image stabilization again benefits Sony, producing noticeably steadier footage, especially at telephoto zoom or handheld walking shots.

If video is a secondary priority in your kit, the Nikon suffices. But for more polished handheld video with zoomed subjects, Sony’s system is a clear winner.

Battery Life, Storage, and Connectivity

Battery life is another area where these models differ significantly. Nikon S5200’s battery offers around 160 shots per charge - modest even by compact standards - potentially limiting on longer outings without backup or charging options.

Sony HX20V doubles that with approximately 320 shots per charge, owing partly to a larger battery pack and more efficient circuitry. For travel photographers or day-long use, the Sony option is more practical.

Storage-wise, both cameras support SD, SDHC, and SDXC cards. Sony adds compatibility with Memory Stick Duo / Pro Duo formats, preserving backward compatibility but adding little for modern users.

Connectivity is sparse on both. Nikon S5200 has Wi-Fi built-in (the early iteration given launch date), enabling basic image transfer - no Bluetooth or NFC support. Sony integrates “Eye-Fi” wireless connection support, designed to synchronize with Eye-Fi branded cards, a niche approach that may complicate wireless workflows for some.

Neither offer HDMI ports with Nikon, while Sony HX20V does provide HDMI output, facilitating easy playback on HDTVs or monitors and potential video capture tethering solutions.

Diving into Use Cases: Which Camera Suits Your Style?

I always find it helpful to contextualize camera strengths against photographic disciplines. Let’s see how each stacks up across various genres.

Portrait Photography

Portraits demand pleasing skin tones, vivid eye detail, and appealing bokeh.

  • Nikon’s modest 6x zoom lens and fixed aperture don’t favor shallow depth of field or variable creative control. Without face or eye detection and lacking manual focus, catching crisp portraits can be challenging, especially in low light.

  • Sony HX20V includes face detection autofocus and manual focus options. Though the small sensor limits bokeh potential, the 20x zoom allows better framing flexibility from a distance, delivering sharper eyes and richer colors.

Verdict: Sony’s autofocus sophistication and zoom edge accord it a noticeable advantage for portrait snapshots.

Landscape Photography

Here, dynamic range, resolution, and weather resistance weigh heavily.

  • Both cameras share similar sensor sizes, but Sony’s slightly higher megapixels facilitate larger prints or detailed crops.

  • Neither camera sports weather sealing or advanced dynamic range modes. Exposure compensation is only available on Sony.

  • Absence of RAW shooting limits detail recovery in shadows/highlights on both.

  • Nikon’s stroke of simplicity aids straightforward shooting but may frustrate landscape enthusiasts who want manual exposure modes.

Verdict: Sony offers greater flexibility and image quality, though neither is ideal for professional landscape work.

Wildlife and Sports

Speed, autofocus accuracy, and zoom reach are pivotal.

  • Nikon lacks continuous autofocus, burst shooting, and telephoto reach - dealbreakers for action or wildlife.

  • Sony shines with 20x zoom, 10 fps bursts, face tracking, and manual focus.

Verdict: Sony is hands down better suited for casual wildlife and sports; Nikon simply can’t keep pace.

Street and Travel Photography

Here, discretion, portability, and battery life matter most.

  • Nikon’s slim, light design makes it an excellent street shooter from a portability standpoint.

  • Sony’s larger body and longer lens add size and weight but bring powerful zoom and better battery life.

  • Nikon’s weaker battery forces carry of spares for a full day.

Verdict: For pure pocketability, Nikon is your companion; Sony grants versatility at the expense of some portability.

Macro and Night Photography

  • Sony claims 1 cm macro focusing, supported by image stabilization, aiding handheld close-ups.

  • Nikon lacks detailed macro specs and stabilization, limiting macro usability.

  • Sony’s higher ISO ceiling (up to 12800 native vs Nikon’s 3200 max) benefits low-light and nighttime shooting.

  • Neither supports advanced exposure modes or manual control critical for stark astro or night photography.

Verdict: Sony is the more capable low-light and macro shooter.

Reliability and Workflow Considerations for Professionals

Even compact cameras sometimes find their way into professional workflows as backups or for impromptu jobs.

Neither Nikon S5200 nor Sony HX20V shoot RAW, which excludes them for serious post-processing workflows relying on high bit-depth files.

Build quality on both is typical consumer-grade plastic; none offer weather sealing or ruggedization.

Sony’s manual focus and exposure compensation can be helpful for controlled shooting, but neither camera would replace a dedicated pro tool.

Battery life and storage options on Sony are more reliable for extended use.

In sum, these cameras are best viewed as versatile companions for casual or enthusiast use rather than professional mainstays.

Summing Up: Scores, Star Performers, and Recommendations

To visualize the overall performance side-by-side, we compiled scores based on sensor performance, feature set, handling, and versatility.

Sony HX20V takes a robust lead owing to its zoom versatility, autofocus features, video specs, and battery life. Nikon S5200 is a niche player excelling in pocketability and simple point-and-shoot ease.

Genre-specific performance charts further cement this:

Sample Imagery: Real-World Snapshots

A picture is worth a thousand words, so here are representative image samples from both cameras - portraits, landscapes, macros, and telephoto shots.

The Sony’s images portray richer detail, better color fidelity, and sharper telephoto captures, while Nikon’s images appear softer with less dynamic range.

Final Verdict: Matching Your Needs

Choose Nikon Coolpix S5200 if you:

  • Want a very compact, lightweight camera that fits easily in your pocket
  • Prioritize simplicity and point-and-shoot ease without fussing over manual controls
  • Shoot largely in well-lit conditions and casual indoor situations
  • Are budgeting around $130 or want a fun basic camera for travel or snapshots

Choose Sony Cyber-shot HX20V if you:

  • Need a versatile compact with extensive zoom reach for wildlife, sports, or travel
  • Desire stronger autofocus, face detection, and manual focus options for creative control
  • Value longer battery life for day trips or extended outings
  • Would benefit from better video specs and image stabilization
  • Can accommodate the larger physical size and price (~$400)

Final Thoughts

The Nikon S5200 and Sony HX20V encapsulate contrasting approaches to compact cameras from a similar era - the Nikon a slimline casual camera, the Sony a feature-packed superzoom with serious photographic chops.

Through exhaustive hands-on testing balancing laboratory metrics with real-world scenarios, I found the Sony HX20V a substantially more capable and flexible tool. It answers the needs of those who want more control, zoom, and shooting speed without locking into higher camera tiers.

Yet the Nikon S5200 retains value for the ultra-light, no-fuss shooter who prioritizes portability over feature set. Knowing these strengths and limits helps align camera choice with your photographic style and expectations.

Photography is as much about readiness and adaptability as gear. Both cameras channel certain aspects of that ethos - yours is to pick which dog is the best boy for your creative walk.

By carefully weighing these factors, you can now decide with confidence where to invest your money and attention when choosing between these two notable compact shooters.

Thanks for reading, and happy shooting!

Nikon S5200 vs Sony HX20V Specifications

Detailed spec comparison table for Nikon S5200 and Sony HX20V
 Nikon Coolpix S5200Sony Cyber-shot DSC-HX20V
General Information
Company Nikon Sony
Model Nikon Coolpix S5200 Sony Cyber-shot DSC-HX20V
Category Small Sensor Compact Small Sensor Superzoom
Introduced 2013-01-29 2012-07-20
Physical type Compact Compact
Sensor Information
Processor - BIONZ
Sensor type BSI-CMOS BSI-CMOS
Sensor size 1/2.3" 1/2.3"
Sensor dimensions 6.16 x 4.62mm 6.17 x 4.55mm
Sensor area 28.5mm² 28.1mm²
Sensor resolution 16 megapixels 18 megapixels
Anti aliasing filter
Aspect ratio - 4:3 and 16:9
Peak resolution 4608 x 3456 4896 x 3672
Highest native ISO 3200 12800
Min native ISO 125 100
RAW data
Autofocusing
Manual focus
Autofocus touch
Continuous autofocus
Autofocus single
Autofocus tracking
Selective autofocus
Center weighted autofocus
Autofocus multi area
Autofocus live view
Face detect focus
Contract detect focus
Phase detect focus
Number of focus points - 9
Cross focus points - -
Lens
Lens mount fixed lens fixed lens
Lens focal range 26-156mm (6.0x) 25-500mm (20.0x)
Maximal aperture - f/3.2-5.8
Macro focus distance - 1cm
Focal length multiplier 5.8 5.8
Screen
Display type Fixed Type Fixed Type
Display diagonal 3" 3"
Resolution of display 460 thousand dots 922 thousand dots
Selfie friendly
Liveview
Touch capability
Display technology TFT-LCD with Anti-reflection coating XtraFine TruBlack TFT LCD
Viewfinder Information
Viewfinder None None
Features
Min shutter speed 4s 30s
Max shutter speed 1/2000s 1/1600s
Continuous shutter rate - 10.0 frames/s
Shutter priority
Aperture priority
Expose Manually
Exposure compensation - Yes
Custom white balance
Image stabilization
Inbuilt flash
Flash range - 7.10 m
Flash settings - Auto, On, Off, Slow Sync
External flash
AE bracketing
WB bracketing
Exposure
Multisegment
Average
Spot
Partial
AF area
Center weighted
Video features
Video resolutions 1920 x 1080 1920 x 1080 (60 fps), 1440 x 1080 (30 fps), 1280 x 720 (30 fps), 640 x 480 (30 fps)
Highest video resolution 1920x1080 1920x1080
Video file format - MPEG-4, AVCHD
Mic port
Headphone port
Connectivity
Wireless Built-In Eye-Fi Connected
Bluetooth
NFC
HDMI
USB USB 2.0 (480 Mbit/sec) USB 2.0 (480 Mbit/sec)
GPS None BuiltIn
Physical
Environmental sealing
Water proof
Dust proof
Shock proof
Crush proof
Freeze proof
Weight 146g (0.32 lb) 254g (0.56 lb)
Dimensions 98 x 58 x 22mm (3.9" x 2.3" x 0.9") 107 x 62 x 35mm (4.2" x 2.4" x 1.4")
DXO scores
DXO Overall score not tested not tested
DXO Color Depth score not tested not tested
DXO Dynamic range score not tested not tested
DXO Low light score not tested not tested
Other
Battery life 160 pictures 320 pictures
Style of battery Battery Pack Battery Pack
Battery model EN-EL19 NP-BG1
Self timer - Yes (2 or 10 sec, Portrait 1/2)
Time lapse recording
Type of storage SD/SDHC/SDXC SD/SDHC/SDXC, Memory Stick Duo/Pro Duo/Pro-HG Duo
Card slots 1 1
Retail cost $130 $397