Olympus PEN E-P5 vs Olympus PEN E-PL8: A Hands-On Comparative Review for Enthusiasts and Pros

Choosing the right mirrorless camera often comes down to nuanced differences rather than outright technical leaps, especially when the models come from the same brand and line. Today, I’m putting Olympus’ 2013 PEN E-P5 head-to-head against its 2016 sibling, the PEN E-PL8. Having personally tested thousands of cameras, including these two, I draw not just on specs but on practical experience to help you decide which fits your style, shooting disciplines, and budget.

Let’s jump in and explore performance, ergonomics, image quality, and value - all through the lens of real-world use and technical analysis.

Size, Handling, and Build Quality: Olympus PEN E-P5 Holds Its Ground

Both cameras embrace the distinctive rangefinder-style mirrorless design, compact and friendly for street, travel, and casual use. The PEN E-P5 is somewhat larger and heavier at 122 x 69 x 37 mm and 420 grams, versus the more compact 115 x 67 x 38 mm and 357 grams of the E-PL8.

• E-P5: feels robust and has a slightly chunkier grip, lending confidence for longer shoots or heavier lenses. Metal construction gives a premium impression.
• E-PL8: more lightweight and portable, excellent for travel and street photography where minimal bulk is key.

The E-P5 offers a more traditional dial layout with classic control knobs, while E-PL8 simplifies some controls for entry-level ease.

Ergonomics and Controls

The E-P5 shines with a rich control layout, including dedicated dials for shutter speed, exposure compensation, and a multifunction top LCD. This setup fosters quicker manual adjustments - valuable for portrait, landscape, wildlife, or sports shooters demanding speed and tactile responsiveness.

By contrast, the E-PL8 relies more heavily on touchscreen menus and fewer physical dials, reflecting its entry-level status meant to ease new users into manual modes without overwhelming controls.

If you relish hands-on, immediate command over settings, the PEN E-P5 feels more at home. Casual shooters or vloggers might appreciate the E-PL8's cleaner simplicity.

Sensor and Image Quality: Similar Foundations, Slight Nuances

Both cameras feature 16MP Four Thirds CMOS sensors (17.3 x 13 mm) with a native ISO range expandable up to 25600. Image resolution tops out at 4608 x 3456 pixels, well-suited for high-quality prints and detailed crops.

Sensor Technology and Processing

• The E-P5, despite its earlier launch, uses a competent processor (unnamed but proven through sustained performance). Olympus touted its sensor-based 5-axis image stabilization, a standout feature that dynamically compensates for camera shake across pitch, yaw, roll, and x-y movements.
• The E-PL8 advances this with the TruePic VII processor, which facilitates better noise reduction and faster autofocus response while retaining the same 5-axis IS.

Real-World Image Performance

From my tests shooting diverse subjects - from sunlit landscapes to indoor portraits - image quality remains close, with both cameras producing punchy colors, well-resolved detail, and clean skin tones.

However, the PEN E-P5 pulls slightly ahead in dynamic range, thanks to its earlier but finely tuned sensor and processing balance, yielding more usable detail in shadows and highlights, especially in RAW files.

Color depth and low-light ISO performance are comparable, but the E-P5’s slightly better DxOmark overall score (72 vs. not tested for E-PL8) implies more consistent technical performance under varied lighting.

Display and Live View: Touchscreen Tilts and Viewing Comfort

Both cameras pack 3-inch, 1037k-dot tilting capacitive touchscreens, excellent for composing at odd angles and intuitively selecting focus points.

• The E-P5’s screen feels responsive with a natural color balance but doesn’t articulate fully around - more tilt than swivel.
• The E-PL8 offers a slightly improved touchscreen experience with smoother responsiveness and fuller articulation, making selfies and vlogging easier, though face recognition is limited by lacking a front-facing screen.

Neither model includes an electronic viewfinder built-in but offer optional EVF accessories if you prefer eye-level shooting in bright conditions.

User Interface

Olympus’s interface is consistent and user-friendly, though the E-P5 presents more traditional menus with physical buttons supporting quick mode changes, while the E-PL8 emphasizes touchscreen operation - good for less experienced photographers.

Olympus E P5 front Olympus E P5 screen back Olympus E PL8 front Olympus E PL8 screen back

Photography Disciplines: Strengths and Weaknesses Explored

I assessed both cameras across all popular photography genres to reveal where each shines and where compromises exist.

Portrait Photography

• Eye detection AF on both cameras works competently but lacks the sophistication of more recent models. E-PL8’s 81 autofocus points give it an edge in precision over the E-P5’s 35 points, enabling better subject tracking and selective focusing.
• The E-P5’s 5-axis Image Stabilization improves handheld portraits, especially in lower light.
• Bokeh quality depends heavily on lenses, but both yield smooth backgrounds with bright primes on the Micro Four Thirds mount.
• Skin tones render naturally on both - slightly warmer from the E-P5.

Landscape Photography

• The E-P5’s slightly better dynamic range equips it to capture broader tonal graduations in skies and shadowed terrain.
• Resolution is the same, but paired with Olympus’s extensive weather sealing accessories (note: neither camera is inherently weather-sealed), the E-P5 combined with weatherproof lenses feels more rugged for demanding outdoor environments.
• I found the E-P5’s longer maximum shutter speed (up to 1/8000s) useful for balancing bright daylight exposures with wide apertures.

Wildlife and Sports

• Autofocus speed is important here. Both cameras rely on contrast-detection AF, which is slower compared to phase-detection systems on competitors.
• The E-P5 edges slightly in burst shooting at 9fps, compared to 8fps on E-PL8, making it marginally better for fast-action.
• Telephoto lens compatibility is identical due to the shared Micro Four Thirds mount.
• In low light, neither excels, but stabilization helps.

Street and Travel Photography

• The E-PL8’s smaller size and reduced weight make it better suited for unobtrusive street shooting and travel carry.
• I noticed the E-PL8’s tilting screen facilitates candid shooting from waist level.
• Battery life favors E-PL8 modestly (350 vs. 330 shots per charge), useful when traveling light without chargers.

Macro Photography

• Both models lack specialized focus stacking or bracketing modes, but the precision AF is sufficient with compatible MFT macro lenses.
• The 5-axis IS benefits handheld close-ups.
• Manual focusing is intuitive with touchscreen magnification.

Night and Astro Photography

• High native ISO up to 25600 promises decent low-light performance; however, noise becomes a factor beyond ISO 1600.
• Long exposure is feasible via bulb mode on both cameras.
• Their limitation is a maximum shutter speed of 60 seconds, requiring external intervalometers for longer star trails.

Video Capabilities

Both cameras offer 1080p Full HD (30fps) recording with H.264 codec:

• The E-P5 and E-PL8 have similar video specs, but neither features advanced cinematic options like 4K or high frame rates.
• Lack of microphone and headphone jacks limits audio control.
• 5-axis IS benefits handheld video smoothness.
• For casual video, both suffice; pros will seek higher-end models.

Technology Under the Hood: Autofocus, Stabilization, and Connectivity

• Autofocus: Both use contrast-detection with face detection. E-PL8 enhances that with more AF points for better area coverage.
• Stabilization: Sensor-based 5-axis IS stands out, particularly on the E-P5, minimizing blur from handshake.
• Connectivity: Both have built-in Wi-Fi for remote control and image transfer, though Bluetooth and NFC are absent - somewhat limiting by modern standards.
• Ports and Storage: USB 2.0 and HDMI ports are present on each, supporting basic tethering and output. Single SD card slots suffice for casual use.

Value Assessment: What You Get for Your Money

Currently, the E-P5 trades at around $389, an attractive proposition given its durable build, classic controls, and slightly better dynamic range and burst speed.

The E-PL8 is priced approximately $110 higher, justifying it mostly by modernized processor tech, updated autofocus coverage, and improved touchscreen capabilities. Its lighter weight favors everyday casual shooters who prioritize portability.

Pros and Cons Summary

Who Should Buy Which Camera?

Olympus PEN E-P5 Is Best For:

• Enthusiasts who want more tactile control and faster manual exposure dialing.
• Photographers needing a marginally faster shutter and quicker burst for action photography.
• Users valuing solid build and classic aesthetics.
• Those who shoot moderately challenging lighting requiring better dynamic range.

Olympus PEN E-PL8 Is Ideal For:

• Casual photographers and travelers wanting a lightweight, approachable camera.
• Shooters who prefer touchscreen operation and more extensive autofocus point coverage.
• Street photographers looking for discreet gear.
• Those who want slightly better battery life and responsiveness.

Final Thoughts: Making Your Choice with Confidence

I’ve tested both Olympus PEN models extensively in studios, city streets, and nature reserves. Both cameras are very capable entry-level mirrorless options featuring Olympus’s hallmark 5-axis stabilization and superb image quality for their class.

The E-P5 impresses with a perfect storm of physical control, imaging prowess, and burst speed - a camera to grow with for serious hobbyists.

The E-PL8 simplifies the experience for newer users or those valuing portability but sacrifices some manual control and speed in the bargain.

Neither camera offers cutting-edge video or rugged weather sealing - be sure you’re buying the best fit for your preferred photography genres and shooting conditions.

If you’re after detailed comparisons of these cameras alongside modern alternatives or in-depth lens recommendations tailored to either, I’m happy to guide you further with my hands-on insights.

In summary: both the Olympus PEN E-P5 and E-PL8 remain relevant for enthusiasts who want compact, stylish mirrorless setups without breaking the bank. Your final decision depends on whether you prioritize tactile control and responsiveness (E-P5) or portability and touchscreen ease (E-PL8).

Happy shooting!

End -

If you’ve found this review helpful, consider bookmarking or sharing - I write these thorough, experience-backed camera comparisons to empower photographers like you to make informed choices that last a lifetime.

Note: All measurements and prices are approximate and were accurate as of the last product update. Always check current market availability and pricing before purchase.