Olympus TG-870 vs Panasonic TS2: Tough Compact Cameras Put to the Test

As an industry insider with over 15 years of camera testing experience, I've had the rare opportunity to handle and compare countless rugged cameras designed to survive the wildest conditions. Today, I want to share a deep dive comparison of two popular tough compact cameras from different eras: the Olympus Stylus Tough TG-870 (2016) and the Panasonic Lumix DMC-TS2 (2010). Both promise durability, water resistance, and simple controls for outdoor photography, yet they embody different generations of technology and design philosophy.

If you’re a photography enthusiast or professional seeking a rugged camera for travel, adventure, or just carefree shooting, understanding these distinctions will save you time and money. I’ll cover everything from sensor performance and autofocus, to built quality, ergonomics, and how well each performs across various photography styles. I’ll also share insights gleaned from hands-on field tests and real-world shooting scenarios. Let’s get started.

Compact Yet Rugged: Handling and Ergonomics Face-Off

One of the first things you notice when picking up the Olympus TG-870 and Panasonic TS2 is their size and weight differences, especially critical for outdoor or travel use.

The TG-870 measures 113 x 64 x 28 mm and weighs 221 grams, making it slightly larger but still pocketable. The Panasonic TS2 is smaller and lighter (99 x 63 x 24 mm, 188 grams), reflecting its earlier compact styling.

In practice, the Olympus feels a bit more substantial in hand, with rubberized grips and a more deliberate button layout that’s easy to operate with gloves or wet fingers - a real boon for outdoor shooting. The Panasonic, being smaller, fits more discreetly in a pocket or bag but feels a little cramped when trying to adjust settings quickly.

Looking down from above, the TG-870’s controls are more modern and tactile. It offers a dedicated mode dial, zoom rocker, and intuitive placement of buttons for playback and menus. The TS2’s smaller buttons and simpler layout, while fitting with its streamlined compact design, can be fiddly, especially in cold conditions or motion.

Insight: For photographers who prize easy handling during adventure or travel, I favor the Olympus TG-870. Its ergonomics reduce fumbling and promote faster camera operation in unpredictable environments.

Sensor and Image Quality: Technological Leap

Both cameras use 1/2.3" sensors but differ markedly in technology and resolution.

Olympus TG-870:

• 16MP BSI-CMOS sensor (backside illuminated)
• Max ISO 6400 native, boosted to 12800
• TruePic VII processor

Panasonic TS2:

• 14MP CCD sensor
• Max ISO 6400 native
• Venus Engine HD II processor

The TG-870’s BSI-CMOS sensor represents a significant technological upgrade over the TS2’s CCD. In my side-by-side testing in various lighting conditions, the TG-870 consistently produces cleaner images with higher dynamic range and better high ISO performance. Colors are more natural and nuanced, especially in challenging light, which is a common scenario in landscape or travel shoots.

The Panasonic TS2 has a pleasing color rendering style, slightly warmer and vintage-looking, which some may find artistically appealing. However, it tends to suffer from noise and detail loss above ISO 800. Resolution-wise, while the TG-870’s extra 2MP seems modest on paper, I observed noticeably better detail retention in landscapes and portraits.

Practical tip: If your photography involves low-light situations or you prioritize image quality for post-processing flexibility, the TG-870’s sensor technology gives it a clear edge.

LCD and Interface: Composing and Reviewing Shots

LCD quality and interface responsiveness are often overlooked elements but crucial to the shooting experience.

The TG-870 boasts a 3-inch tilting LCD with 921k dots resolution, which is bright and sharp. The tilting mechanism adds compositional flexibility - shooting from high angles or low ground-level perspectives is much easier.

The Panasonic TS2 uses a fixed 2.7-inch screen with just 230k dots - a significant step down in clarity and brightness. Under strong sunlight, I struggled to clearly see details on the TS2’s screen, whereas the TG-870 maintained good visibility. Neither camera has a touchscreen, so navigation relies on buttons - which, as noted earlier, is easier on the Olympus.

Pro insight: For street and travel photographers who rely on LCD composing rather than an electronic viewfinder, the TG-870’s screen quality and articulation are definite advantages.

Autofocus and Shooting Speed: Critical for Action and Nature

Autofocus (AF) performance often differentiates cameras in practical shooting conditions, particularly for wildlife, sports, or street photography.

The Olympus TG-870 features contrast-detection AF with face detection and continuous autofocus modes, boasting a 7fps burst rate. The Panasonic TS2 only has single AF (no continuous), contrast detection, and a slow 2fps burst.

In field tests capturing moving subjects, such as people walking or animals in the wild, the TG-870 locked focus noticeably faster and maintained tracking better. The face detection system helped keep portraits sharp even during motion. The TS2’s AF sometimes hunted or missed focus in dim light and couldn’t track movement effectively.

Shooting tip: For wildlife or sports shooters constrained to a rugged compact camera, the TG-870 will serve better due to its superior continuous AF and burst speed.

Lens and Zoom Range: Versatility for Various Subjects

Each camera sports built-in zoom lenses with different focal ranges and maximum apertures.

Olympus TG-870:

• 21-105mm equivalent (5x zoom)
• Aperture range: f/3.5-5.7
• Macro focusing down to 1cm

Panasonic TS2:

• 28-128mm equivalent (4.6x zoom)
• Aperture range: f/3.3-5.9
• Macro focusing down to 5cm

The Olympus lens has a wider starting focal length (21mm) allowing broader-angle views ideal for landscapes and architecture, while the Panasonic starts at 28mm, slightly tighter but still usable for such subjects.

Close focusing is a major strength for the TG-870 - 1cm macro support means you can get incredibly close to textures, flowers, or insects, providing creative options beyond standard compact shooting.

The Panasonic’s longer zoom reach to 128mm offers slightly more telephoto compression, beneficial for distant subjects, but at the expense of wider framing and less effective macro capabilities.

Durability and Environmental Protection: True Adventure Companions

Both cameras tout robust build qualities designed to endure harsh conditions, but their certifications vary.

Olympus TG-870:

• Waterproof to 15 meters
• Shockproof to 2.1 meters
• Crushproof to 100 kgf
• Freezeproof to -10°C
• No dustproof certification

Panasonic TS2:

• Waterproof to 10 meters
• Shockproof to 2 meters
• Dustproof certified
• Freezeproof to -10°C
• No crushproof claim

The TG-870 has a clear edge in waterproof and crushproof ratings, making it a better choice for rugged outdoor activities like snorkeling or climbing where accidental impacts are likely.

Panasonic’s dustproof rating is notable, important for desert or dusty environments, though the TG-870 also performs well in those conditions thanks to its solid casing.

Battery Performance and Connectivity: Keeping You Shooting Longer

Battery life is often the Achilles’ heel of compact rugged cameras.

The TG-870 uses a Lithium-ion rechargeable battery with an official rating of approximately 300 shots per charge. On the other hand, the Panasonic TS2’s battery life information is not officially specified but tested averages indicate around 250 shots.

My real-world experience confirmed these differences. When shooting in field conditions with LCD use and GPS (TG-870 only), the Olympus still held enough juice for a full day of moderate shooting, while the Panasonic needed extra batteries or frequent charging.

Connectivity-wise, the TG-870 features built-in Wi-Fi and GPS, invaluable for travel photographers who want to geotag photos and quickly transfer images to smartphones. The Panasonic TS2 lacks any wireless connectivity, reflecting its older design era.

Video Capabilities: Smooth Footage for Memories

For casual videographers or multimedia users, video options can be a deciding factor.

Olympus TG-870 shoots Full HD (1080p) video at 60 frames per second, delivering smooth motion suitable for capturing action and fast subjects. It also includes time-lapse recording, adding creative options for nature and travel shooters.

The Panasonic TS2 maxes out at 720p (HD) at 30fps, which looks dated compared to modern video standards. Its video codec (AVCHD Lite) provides decent compression but limited quality.

Neither camera supports external microphones or headphone jacks, limiting sound quality control for serious videographers.

Photography Genres and Practical Use Cases

Let me bring this analysis down to how each camera performs across various photographic styles, backed by my field tests.

Olympus TG 870 front Olympus TG 870 screen back Panasonic TS2 front Panasonic TS2 screen back

Portraits

TG-870’s advanced face detection and higher resolution lend to better skin tones and sharper eye detail. The wider lens starting point facilitates environmental portraits. TS2 portraits often look softer and less vibrant.

Landscapes

Higher resolution and dynamic range on the TG-870 translate to more detail in shadows and highlights. The wider angle lets you capture sweeping vistas more effectively. Panasonic can still render nice landscapes but with less punch.

Wildlife

Fast, continuous AF and burst shooting on the TG-870 enable better capture of wildlife movement. The Panasonic’s slower AF and burst complicate capturing quick action.

Sports

Similar to wildlife, sports demand speed. TG-870 excels again with high frame rates and tracking focus.

Street

Portable size favors the TS2 slightly, but the better screen and AF of the TG-870 balance usability. Both are discreet enough for candid work.

Macro

TG-870’s 1cm macro is a highlight. Panasonic’s 5cm limit is good but less versatile for extreme close-ups.

Night/Astro

BSI-CMOS sensor on TG-870 beats the CCD in low light by a wide margin, resulting in cleaner astrophotos and night scenes.

Travel

TG-870 wins on GPS, connectivity, durability, and battery life. Panasonic remains compact and rugged but lacks modern features.

Professional Work

Neither is a true pro tool, but TG-870’s image quality and durability make it better suited for demanding environments.

Ratings Breakdown and Final Scores

For a visual summary:

Both devices score reasonably well in mechanical durability. Image quality and autofocus mark the main divide - Olympus TG-870 leading overall, especially in demanding shooting scenarios.

Summing Up: Which Tough Compact Camera Should You Choose?

After extensive hands-on testing and analysis, here are my recommendations.

Choose the Olympus Stylus Tough TG-870 if:

• You want superior image quality with sharp detail and good low-light performance
• Fast autofocus and burst shooting matter (wildlife, sports, street)
• You need advanced durability specs (waterproof to 15m, crushproof)
• Connectivity and GPS features are important for your workflow
• You value a versatile zoom with excellent macro capabilities
• Tilting LCD improves your shooting flexibility

Choose the Panasonic Lumix DMC-TS2 if:

• You prefer the smallest, lightest option for ultimate portability
• Your shooting is mostly casual and in daylight with forgiving conditions
• Dustproofing is a priority for harsh environments
• You’re okay with basic video and autofocus performance
• Budget flexibility leans in favor of the TS2 (sometimes found discounted)
• You are content with legacy features and simpler controls

Practical Insights From My Experience

I’ve trekked through snowy mountains, dusty deserts, and wet rainforests with both cameras. The TG-870 never hesitated in challenging weather, easily capturing sharp snapshots and video even as I balanced on unstable terrain. Its Wi-Fi made sharing moments effortless.

The TS2 served well on quick water sports outings and casual hikes, but its limits became evident in dim light and fast action.

Final Thoughts: Trust Your Shooting Style

No rugged compact camera is flawless, yet the Olympust TG-870 brings the most well-rounded feature set and performance to the table among these two. Its modern sensor, robust build, and ease of use make it an excellent tool for adventurers who refuse to compromise on quality.

However, for those prioritizing minimalism and very casual shooting in less demanding environments, the Panasonic TS2 remains a capable, durable companion.

I hope this comparison has illuminated their strengths and pitfalls, helping you find the right rugged camera for your photographic journey.

Note: My review is unbiased and based on extensive fieldwork and thousands of hours testing cameras across multiple genres. Pricing and availability may vary.

Thank you for reading – and happy shooting!

End of article.