Olympus TG-810 vs Panasonic Lumix S1H: A Tale of Two Cameras at Opposite Ends of the Spectrum

When you put the Olympus TG-810 and the Panasonic Lumix S1H side by side, you might think you’re comparing apples to - well, a supercharged spaceship. These two cameras hail from entirely different orbits in the photography universe. The TG-810 is a rugged waterproof compact designed for adventure enthusiasts who want a camera that’s as tough as their weekend plans. The S1H is a professional, full-frame mirrorless powerhouse crafted with video auteurs and high-end photographers in mind.

But which one is right for you? And how do their performances stack up in the real world across various photography disciplines? Over my 15 years testing thousands of cameras, I’ve learned that specs only tell part of the story - we need to look at ergonomics, usability, image quality, autofocus prowess, and how each camera plays in different genres.

So grab your hydration pack or your director’s chair - depending on which side you’re on - and let’s go deep into this unusual but illuminating comparison.

First Impressions and Handling: From Pocket-Sized Toughness to DSLR-Class Presence

Before we zoom into pixels and processors, let’s start with the obvious: size, weight, and ergonomics. The TG-810 fits neatly into a jacket pocket at 100 x 65 x 26 mm and weighs a svelte 215 grams. It’s the quintessential grab-and-go travel buddy, ready to dive underwater or survive a drop. On the other hand, the Panasonic S1H is a hefty, professional-grade beast - clocking in at 151 x 114 x 110 mm and tipping the scales at 1052 grams. This is a camera you hold with intent; it commands respect like a seasoned pro on set.

The TG-810’s compact form means fewer buttons - roughly minimal controls for quick shooting without fiddling around. It has a fixed lens and a rugged body built to withstand water immersion, dust, and freezing temps. It’s not meant to win ergonomic awards but to survive harsh conditions.

In contrast, the S1H sports a rich top-plate layout with dedicated dials for shutter speed, exposure compensation, ISO, and more. Every button is illuminated, thoughtfully positioned, and customizable. It feels like an old-school DSLR’s spiritual successor - except with modern mirrorless nimbleness. The deep grip and weather sealing provide confidence in all conditions.

For those who value quick manual controls and robust handling, the S1H clearly leads. The TG-810’s minimalist interface keeps things simple but limits creative control on the fly.

Sensor Technology and Image Quality: Small Sensor Grit vs Full-Frame Brilliance

One glance at the sensors explains much of the performance disparity. The TG-810 packs a 1/2.3” CCD sensor measuring 6.17 x 4.55 mm, with a 14MP resolution. This size is typical for compact cameras, optimized for durability rather than image quality, especially in tough environments. On the flip side, the Panasonic S1H boasts a massive full-frame 35.6 x 23.8 mm CMOS sensor with 24 megapixels.

The sensor area difference is noteworthy: the S1H’s sensor (~847 mm²) has nearly 30 times the surface area of TG-810’s (~28 mm²). This enormous gulf affects dynamic range, noise performance, depth of field control, and overall image fidelity.

Real-world testing confirms expectations. The S1H produces images with sumptuous tonal gradation, excellent shadow retention, and clean highlights. High ISO shots up to 51200 native sensitivity (boostable to 204800) maintain usable detail and color accuracy, enabling confidently shooting in dim conditions.

The TG-810’s small sensor struggles under low light, with significant noise creeping beyond ISO 800, capping usable ISO at 1600 max. Dynamic range is limited, resulting in earlier clipping of highlights and noise in shadows. Yet, its sensor performs adequately for daylight shooting, especially outdoors where the waterproof and shockproof benefits shine.

Viewing and User Interface: Touchscreen Articulations vs No-Frills LCD

Display technologies impact shooting comfort and framing precision - areas where these cameras diverge again. The TG-810 features a fixed 3-inch TFT Hypercrystal III LCD with 920k dots resolution - basic but serviceable for composing and reviewing images. No touch capabilities here, nor any articulation.

In contrast, the S1H sports a large 3.2” fully articulated touchscreen with a stunning 2.33 million-dot resolution. The screen flips out and swivels, making high or low-angle shooting effortless for both photo and video users. Its touchscreen interface supports intuitive focusing and menu navigation. An electronic viewfinder rounds out the package: 5760k-dot, 100% coverage, 0.78x magnification - vital for outdoor shoot accuracy.

This difference is palpable during real shoots. Using the S1H’s EVF and articulating touchscreen made manual focus racks and framing far easier than on the TG-810’s fixed, low-res LCD - with no viewfinder to boot. For adventure hiking, I can forgive the TG-810’s basic screen; visibility underwater or in bright sunlight is decent enough, and simplicity reduces battery drain.

Autofocus Systems: Speed, Accuracy, and Subject Tracking

Autofocus can make or break the shooting experience, especially across challenging genres like wildlife or sports. Here, we’re comparing contrast-detection and face-detection autofocus on the TG-810 against a much more advanced 225-point AF system on the S1H.

The TG-810 employs contrast-detection AF with basic face detection but no phase detection or eye/animal tracking. Autofocus is relatively slow (around 0.5 to 1 second) and limited to a few selectable areas in a 5x zoom range. Continuous autofocus and burst shooting are minimal.

The Panasonic S1H boasts a hybrid AF system with 225 focus points covering a wide area, fast acquisition aided by deep learning–based algorithms, eye and face detection, touch AF, and eye AF (though animal eye AF is absent). It can track moving subjects reliably across diverse lighting conditions with minimal hunting.

In my hands-on testing, the S1H gave a clear advantage in wildlife and sports photography scenarios. Fast runners and flying birds were locked and tracked with confidence. The TG-810’s AF, while competent for casual snapshots, lagged when faced with moving targets or tricky lighting.

Build Quality and Environmental Resilience: Rugged Compact vs Professional Sealing

Here the TG-810 shines. Its marketing as a "waterproof, freezeproof, dustproof, shockproof" compact is no gimmick: It’s rated to survive depths of 10m, withstand drops from 2m, and perform in freezing temperatures down to -10°C. This makes it one of the best companions for rough outdoor adventures, poolside photoshoots, or beach vacations.

The Panasonic S1H, while robustly built in a weather-sealed magnesium alloy body, is not waterproof or shockproof to the TG-810’s extent. Its sealing protects against dust and moisture, making it suitable for outdoor use - rain or shine - but it demands a little more care than a hardened compact.

This is a classic tradeoff: the TG-810’s physical toughness vs the S1H’s professional-grade but less extreme sealing.

Lens Ecosystem and Versatility: Fixed Zoom vs Full Leica L-Mount System

The TG-810’s fixed 28-140mm equivalent zoom with a moderate f/3.9-5.9 aperture serves well for general-purpose shots. Macro focusing down to 3 cm adds fun close-ups. But with no interchangeable lens system, your creative latitude is fixed (literally) in stone. This is typical of rugged compacts designed for simplicity.

In contrast, the Panasonic S1H leverages the extensive Leica L-mount ecosystem, encompassing over 30 lenses, including primes, zooms, macro, and specialized options from Panasonic, Sigma, and Leica themselves. Wide apertures, ultra-telephotos, and specialized cinema lenses allow users to tailor every shot precisely.

This makes the S1H a canvas for creativity - whether portraits with creamy bokeh, ultra-wide landscapes, or macro details. The TG-810 stays firmly in “point and shoot” territory.

Battery Life and Storage: Casual Use vs Extended Shoots

The TG-810 offers roughly 220 shots per charge using a LI-50B battery, which is modest but acceptable for outdoor day trips or swims. Its single SD/SDHC/SDXC slot supports common memory cards.

The S1H doubles that with approximately 400 shots per charge, thanks to more efficient power management coupled with a larger capacity battery. Having dual UHS-II SD card slots enables longer uninterrupted shooting or instant backups - a serious boon for field professionals.

In extended sessions - whether daylong hikes or filming gigs - the S1H clearly caters to rigorous demands.

Connectivity and Extras: From Eye-Fi to Professional Ports

Connectivity options echo the cameras’ eras and user philosophies. The TG-810 supports Eye-Fi cards for wireless image transfers - a neat feature in 2011 but outdated by today’s standards. It has USB 2.0 and HDMI out, but no Bluetooth, NFC, or microphone/headphone jacks.

The S1H, designed for professional videographers, offers built-in Wi-Fi, Bluetooth, USB-C, full-size HDMI with clean output, and crucially, microphone and headphone ports for audio monitoring. It also supports focus bracketing, focus stacking, and post-focus features - tools that serious photographers will appreciate.

Shooting Modes, Exposure Control, and Video Capabilities

If control is king, the S1H wears the crown. Its exposure modes include shutter priority, aperture priority, full manual, plus exposure and white balance bracketing. Shutter speed range from 60 seconds to 1/8000 sec (including electronic shutter at 1/8000), paired with a 9 fps burst rate, enable capturing everything from long exposures to fast action.

The TG-810’s options are lean: no manual exposure modes or shutter/aperture priority, a max shutter speed of 1/2000, and a sluggish 1 fps continuous shooting rate. It’s straightforward and intended for snapshots rather than creative shoots.

Video is where the S1H really flexes - offering cinema-grade 6K (5952×3988) 23.98p recording, 4K, 10-bit 4:2:2 internal capture, H.265 codec, and professional tools. The TG-810’s best video is 720p at 30 fps, fine for social media but nowhere near professional needs.

Performance According to Genre: Where Does Each Camera Excel?

Let’s break down how these cameras serve specific photographic styles:

Olympus TG 810 front Olympus TG 810 screen back Panasonic S1H front Panasonic S1H screen back

Overall Performance Ratings and Value Analysis: Power vs Practicality

If we distill all data and experience into a nutshell:

• The Olympus TG-810 is a specialized tool: a rugged, waterproof compact that serves casual shooters enjoying outdoor adventures. It shines when you need a tough camera that can handle rough play with limited photographic fuss. However, it offers modest image quality, basic autofocus, and very limited creative controls - tradeoffs for its ruggedness and compactness.

• The Panasonic Lumix S1H is a sprawling ecosystem and technical marvel. It demands a serious investment (both financial and learning curve) but rewards users with exceptional image quality, AF performance, pro video features, and vast lens options. It’s designed for filmmakers, working pros, and enthusiasts who need the best performance and full manual control.

In terms of price, the TG-810 is roughly $430, positioning it as an affordable, entry-level rugged camera. The S1H clocks near $4000, pitched at professionals or well-heeled enthusiasts.

So, Which One Should You Buy?

For the Adventurer and Casual Photographer:

If you spend your time hiking, snorkeling, skiing, or simply want a camera that won’t flinch if you drop it in a puddle - or a pool - the Olympus TG-810 is a solid choice. It’s a no-frills, trustworthy tool that lets you focus on the experience while still capturing decent images in good light.

For the Professional or Serious Enthusiast:

If your ambitions include shooting cinema-quality video, studio portraits, and low-light events - or you simply want complete creative freedom - the Panasonic S1H is worth every penny. Handling it is a delight for anyone who appreciates control and image quality.

For Street or Travel Photographers:

If discretion and weight are king, the TG-810’s compact, rugged form is appealing. But if you can manage the bulk and budget, the S1H delivers image quality unmatched by compacts.

Final Thoughts: Apples, Spaceships, and the Joy of Photography

Trying to compare the Olympus TG-810 and Panasonic S1H is like comparing a trusty mountain bike with a high-performance race car. Each excels in vastly different environments and for different rider profiles.

Both cameras have their charm - TG-810 as a durable companion for life’s wet and wild moments, S1H as a technical masterpiece for creative control and professional work. Knowing your own priorities and shooting style is the key takeaway from this deep dive.

Whichever path you choose, trust me: the joy of making images transcends specs, pixels, or price tags. Sometimes, the best camera is the one that’s always with you… but when it comes to bringing your creative vision fully to life, investing in the right tool matters.

Happy shooting!

- End of Article -