Samsung PL170 vs Sigma SD1
99 Imaging
39 Features
20 Overall
31
77 Imaging
55 Features
43 Overall
50
Samsung PL170 vs Sigma SD1 Key Specs
(Full Review)
- 16MP - 1/2.3" Sensor
- 3" Fixed Screen
- ISO 0 - 3200
- 1280 x 720 video
- ()mm (F) lens
- n/ag - 95 x 57 x 19mm
- Revealed January 2011
(Full Review)
- 15MP - APS-C Sensor
- 3" Fixed Display
- ISO 0 - 0
- No Video
- Sigma SA Mount
- n/ag - 146 x 113 x 80mm
- Released September 2010
- Refreshed by Sigma SD1 Merrill
Samsung PL170 vs Sigma SD1 Overview
On this page, we are looking at the Samsung PL170 vs Sigma SD1, one being a Ultracompact and the other is a Advanced DSLR by rivals Samsung and Sigma. The image resolution of the PL170 (16MP) and the SD1 (15MP) is very comparable but the PL170 (1/2.3") and SD1 (APS-C) provide totally different sensor measurements.
Japan-exclusive Leica Leitz Phone 3 features big sensor and new modesThe PL170 was revealed 4 months later than the SD1 so they are both of a similar generation. Both of these cameras have different body design with the Samsung PL170 being a Ultracompact camera and the Sigma SD1 being a Mid-size SLR camera.
Before delving straight to a detailed comparison, here is a quick overview of how the PL170 grades vs the SD1 for portability, imaging, features and an overall rating.
Samsung PL170 vs Sigma SD1 Gallery
Here is a sample of the gallery pics for Samsung PL170 and Sigma SD1. The full galleries are provided at Samsung PL170 Gallery and Sigma SD1 Gallery.
Reasons to pick Samsung PL170 over the Sigma SD1
PL170 | SD1 |
---|
Reasons to pick Sigma SD1 over the Samsung PL170
SD1 | PL170 | |||
---|---|---|---|---|
Manual focus | More precise focus | |||
Display resolution | 460k | 230k | Crisper display (+230k dot) |
Common features in the Samsung PL170 and Sigma SD1
PL170 | SD1 | |||
---|---|---|---|---|
Released | January 2011 | September 2010 | Same generation | |
Display type | Fixed | Fixed | Fixed display | |
Display dimensions | 3" | 3" | Equal display measurements | |
Selfie screen | Neither offers selfie screen | |||
Touch display | Neither offers Touch display |
Samsung PL170 vs Sigma SD1 Physical Comparison
If you're planning to carry your camera, you should factor its weight and volume. The Samsung PL170 offers exterior measurements of 95mm x 57mm x 19mm (3.7" x 2.2" x 0.7") accompanied by a weight of n/a grams (0.00 lbs) and the Sigma SD1 has sizing of 146mm x 113mm x 80mm (5.7" x 4.4" x 3.1") having a weight of n/a grams (0.00 lbs).
Take a look at the Samsung PL170 vs Sigma SD1 in the latest Camera and Lens Size Comparison Tool.Do not forget, the weight of an Interchangeable Lens Camera will differ depending on the lens you are employing at that moment. Below is a front view dimensions comparison of the PL170 vs the SD1.
Taking into consideration dimensions and weight, the portability grade of the PL170 and SD1 is 99 and 77 respectively.
Samsung PL170 vs Sigma SD1 Sensor Comparison
Normally, it is tough to envision the difference in sensor sizing just by seeing technical specs. The visual underneath might offer you a stronger sense of the sensor measurements in the PL170 and SD1.
As you have seen, each of these cameras provide different resolutions and different sensor sizing. The PL170 using its smaller sensor will make achieving bokeh harder and the Samsung PL170 will show extra detail because of its extra 1MP. Greater resolution will allow you to crop photos more aggressively.
Samsung PL170 vs Sigma SD1 Screen and ViewFinder
Photography Type Scores
Portrait Comparison
Street Comparison
Sports Comparison
Travel Comparison
Landscape Comparison
Vlogging Comparison
Samsung PL170 vs Sigma SD1 Specifications
Samsung PL170 | Sigma SD1 | |
---|---|---|
General Information | ||
Company | Samsung | Sigma |
Model | Samsung PL170 | Sigma SD1 |
Class | Ultracompact | Advanced DSLR |
Revealed | 2011-01-05 | 2010-09-21 |
Physical type | Ultracompact | Mid-size SLR |
Sensor Information | ||
Processor | - | Dual True II |
Sensor type | CCD | CMOS (Foveon X3) |
Sensor size | 1/2.3" | APS-C |
Sensor dimensions | 6.08 x 4.56mm | 24 x 16mm |
Sensor surface area | 27.7mm² | 384.0mm² |
Sensor resolution | 16MP | 15MP |
Anti aliasing filter | ||
Maximum resolution | 4608 x 3456 | 4800 x 3200 |
Maximum native ISO | 3200 | - |
Minimum native ISO | - | - |
RAW format | ||
Autofocusing | ||
Focus manually | ||
Touch focus | ||
Continuous AF | ||
Single AF | ||
Tracking AF | ||
AF selectice | ||
Center weighted AF | ||
AF multi area | ||
Live view AF | ||
Face detection focusing | ||
Contract detection focusing | ||
Phase detection focusing | ||
Number of focus points | - | 11 |
Cross focus points | - | 2 |
Lens | ||
Lens mount | fixed lens | Sigma SA |
Lens focal range | () | - |
Available lenses | - | 76 |
Crop factor | 5.9 | 1.5 |
Screen | ||
Type of screen | Fixed Type | Fixed Type |
Screen size | 3 inch | 3 inch |
Screen resolution | 230k dots | 460k dots |
Selfie friendly | ||
Liveview | ||
Touch capability | ||
Viewfinder Information | ||
Viewfinder | None | Optical (pentaprism) |
Viewfinder coverage | - | 96 percent |
Viewfinder magnification | - | 0.64x |
Features | ||
Slowest shutter speed | 8 secs | 15 secs |
Maximum shutter speed | 1/2000 secs | 1/2000 secs |
Continuous shooting rate | - | 5.0fps |
Shutter priority | ||
Aperture priority | ||
Expose Manually | ||
Exposure compensation | - | Yes |
Change WB | ||
Image stabilization | ||
Built-in flash | ||
Hot shoe | ||
Auto exposure bracketing | ||
White balance bracketing | ||
Exposure | ||
Multisegment exposure | ||
Average exposure | ||
Spot exposure | ||
Partial exposure | ||
AF area exposure | ||
Center weighted exposure | ||
Video features | ||
Supported video resolutions | 1280 x 720 | - |
Maximum video resolution | 1280x720 | None |
Mic support | ||
Headphone support | ||
Connectivity | ||
Wireless | None | None |
Bluetooth | ||
NFC | ||
HDMI | ||
USB | none | USB 2.0 (480 Mbit/sec) |
GPS | None | None |
Physical | ||
Environment sealing | ||
Water proof | ||
Dust proof | ||
Shock proof | ||
Crush proof | ||
Freeze proof | ||
Physical dimensions | 95 x 57 x 19mm (3.7" x 2.2" x 0.7") | 146 x 113 x 80mm (5.7" x 4.4" x 3.1") |
DXO scores | ||
DXO All around score | not tested | not tested |
DXO Color Depth score | not tested | not tested |
DXO Dynamic range score | not tested | not tested |
DXO Low light score | not tested | not tested |
Other | ||
Self timer | - | Yes |
Time lapse recording | ||
Storage type | - | Compact Flash (Type I, UDMA compatible) |
Card slots | 1 | 1 |
Cost at launch | $175 | $2,339 |