Clicky

Samsung PL170 vs Sigma SD1

Portability
99
Imaging
39
Features
20
Overall
31
Samsung PL170 front
 
Sigma SD1 front
Portability
77
Imaging
55
Features
43
Overall
50

Samsung PL170 vs Sigma SD1 Key Specs

Samsung PL170
(Full Review)
  • 16MP - 1/2.3" Sensor
  • 3" Fixed Screen
  • ISO 0 - 3200
  • 1280 x 720 video
  • ()mm (F) lens
  • n/ag - 95 x 57 x 19mm
  • Revealed January 2011
Sigma SD1
(Full Review)
  • 15MP - APS-C Sensor
  • 3" Fixed Display
  • ISO 0 - 0
  • No Video
  • Sigma SA Mount
  • n/ag - 146 x 113 x 80mm
  • Released September 2010
  • Refreshed by Sigma SD1 Merrill
Meta to Introduce 'AI-Generated' Labels for Media starting next month

Samsung PL170 vs Sigma SD1 Overview

On this page, we are looking at the Samsung PL170 vs Sigma SD1, one being a Ultracompact and the other is a Advanced DSLR by rivals Samsung and Sigma. The image resolution of the PL170 (16MP) and the SD1 (15MP) is very comparable but the PL170 (1/2.3") and SD1 (APS-C) provide totally different sensor measurements.

Japan-exclusive Leica Leitz Phone 3 features big sensor and new modes

The PL170 was revealed 4 months later than the SD1 so they are both of a similar generation. Both of these cameras have different body design with the Samsung PL170 being a Ultracompact camera and the Sigma SD1 being a Mid-size SLR camera.

Before delving straight to a detailed comparison, here is a quick overview of how the PL170 grades vs the SD1 for portability, imaging, features and an overall rating.

Apple Innovates by Creating Next-Level Optical Stabilization for iPhone
	
	

Reasons to pick Samsung PL170 over the Sigma SD1

 PL170 SD1 

Reasons to pick Sigma SD1 over the Samsung PL170

 SD1 PL170 
Manual focus More precise focus
Display resolution460k230kCrisper display (+230k dot)

Common features in the Samsung PL170 and Sigma SD1

 PL170 SD1 
ReleasedJanuary 2011September 2010Same generation
Display typeFixed Fixed Fixed display
Display dimensions3"3"Equal display measurements
Selfie screen Neither offers selfie screen
Touch display Neither offers Touch display

Samsung PL170 vs Sigma SD1 Physical Comparison

If you're planning to carry your camera, you should factor its weight and volume. The Samsung PL170 offers exterior measurements of 95mm x 57mm x 19mm (3.7" x 2.2" x 0.7") accompanied by a weight of n/a grams (0.00 lbs) and the Sigma SD1 has sizing of 146mm x 113mm x 80mm (5.7" x 4.4" x 3.1") having a weight of n/a grams (0.00 lbs).

Take a look at the Samsung PL170 vs Sigma SD1 in the latest Camera and Lens Size Comparison Tool. Camera Size Comparison with Lenses

Do not forget, the weight of an Interchangeable Lens Camera will differ depending on the lens you are employing at that moment. Below is a front view dimensions comparison of the PL170 vs the SD1.

Samsung PL170 vs Sigma SD1 size comparison

Taking into consideration dimensions and weight, the portability grade of the PL170 and SD1 is 99 and 77 respectively.

Samsung PL170 vs Sigma SD1 top view buttons comparison

Samsung PL170 vs Sigma SD1 Sensor Comparison

Normally, it is tough to envision the difference in sensor sizing just by seeing technical specs. The visual underneath might offer you a stronger sense of the sensor measurements in the PL170 and SD1.

As you have seen, each of these cameras provide different resolutions and different sensor sizing. The PL170 using its smaller sensor will make achieving bokeh harder and the Samsung PL170 will show extra detail because of its extra 1MP. Greater resolution will allow you to crop photos more aggressively.

Samsung PL170 vs Sigma SD1 sensor size comparison

Samsung PL170 vs Sigma SD1 Screen and ViewFinder

Samsung PL170 vs Sigma SD1 Screen and Viewfinder comparison
Pentax 17 Pre-Orders Outperform Expectations by a Landslide

Photography Type Scores

Portrait Comparison

Samsung PL170 Portrait photography info
Sigma SD1 Portrait photography info
30
decent sensor resolution (16 megapixels)
manual focus not available
no manual exposure
no external flash support
tiny sensor (1/2.3")
does not have RAW support
65
focusing manually
sensor resolution is decent (15 megapixels)
nice sensor size (APS-C)
saves RAW files
no liveview
Samsung Releases Faster Versions of EVO MicroSD Cards

Street Comparison

Samsung PL170 Street photography info
Sigma SD1 Street photography info
50
screen does not articulate
does not have image stabilization
tiny sensor (1/2.3")
does not have RAW support
62
nice sensor size (APS-C)
saves RAW files
weather proof
no moving screen
no image stabilization
low maximum ISO (0)
Snapchat Adds Watermarks to AI-Created Images

Sports Comparison

Samsung PL170 Sports photography highlights
Sigma SD1 Sports photography highlights
27
decent sensor resolution (16 megapixels)
focal length is fixed (()mm)
no shutter priority
does not have image stabilization
tiny sensor (1/2.3")
does not have phase detect AF
56
sensor resolution is decent (15 megapixels)
nice sensor size (APS-C)
weather proof
sensor has phase detect autofocus
no liveview
painfully slow continuous shooting (5.0 frames/s)
no image stabilization
Sora from OpenAI releases its first ever music video

Travel Comparison

Samsung PL170 Travel photography features
Sigma SD1 Travel photography features
71
decent sensor resolution (16MP)
flash built-in
great maximum aperture (f)
does not have Timelapse mode
does not posses selfie friendly screen
65
weather proof
sensor resolution is decent (15MP)
has built in flash
no Time Lapse function
screen isn't selfie friendly
Photobucket discusses licensing 13 billion images with AI firms

Landscape Comparison

Samsung PL170 as a Landscape photography camera
Sigma SD1 as a Landscape photography camera
39
great maximum aperture (f)
screen size is decent (3 inches)
decent sensor resolution (16MP)
manual focus not available
cannot change lenses (fixed lens mount)
focal length is fixed (()mm)
no manual exposure
does not have image stabilization
tiny sensor (1/2.3")
does not have RAW support
does not have Timelapse mode
61
focusing manually
swap lenses (Sigma SA mount)
screen size is decent (3")
sensor resolution is decent (15MP)
nice sensor size (APS-C)
saves RAW files
weather proof
no liveview
no image stabilization
low maximum ISO (0)
no Time Lapse function
President Biden pushes bill mandating TikTok sale or ban

Vlogging Comparison

Vlogging with Samsung PL170
Vlogging with Sigma SD1
27
great maximum aperture (f)
does not posses selfie friendly screen
does not have image stabilization
video quality not great (1280 x 720 resolution)
does not have external microphone support
9
no video
Photography Glossary

Samsung PL170 vs Sigma SD1 Specifications

Detailed spec comparison table for Samsung PL170 and Sigma SD1
 Samsung PL170Sigma SD1
General Information
Company Samsung Sigma
Model Samsung PL170 Sigma SD1
Class Ultracompact Advanced DSLR
Revealed 2011-01-05 2010-09-21
Physical type Ultracompact Mid-size SLR
Sensor Information
Processor - Dual True II
Sensor type CCD CMOS (Foveon X3)
Sensor size 1/2.3" APS-C
Sensor dimensions 6.08 x 4.56mm 24 x 16mm
Sensor surface area 27.7mm² 384.0mm²
Sensor resolution 16MP 15MP
Anti aliasing filter
Maximum resolution 4608 x 3456 4800 x 3200
Maximum native ISO 3200 -
Minimum native ISO - -
RAW format
Autofocusing
Focus manually
Touch focus
Continuous AF
Single AF
Tracking AF
AF selectice
Center weighted AF
AF multi area
Live view AF
Face detection focusing
Contract detection focusing
Phase detection focusing
Number of focus points - 11
Cross focus points - 2
Lens
Lens mount fixed lens Sigma SA
Lens focal range () -
Available lenses - 76
Crop factor 5.9 1.5
Screen
Type of screen Fixed Type Fixed Type
Screen size 3 inch 3 inch
Screen resolution 230k dots 460k dots
Selfie friendly
Liveview
Touch capability
Viewfinder Information
Viewfinder None Optical (pentaprism)
Viewfinder coverage - 96 percent
Viewfinder magnification - 0.64x
Features
Slowest shutter speed 8 secs 15 secs
Maximum shutter speed 1/2000 secs 1/2000 secs
Continuous shooting rate - 5.0fps
Shutter priority
Aperture priority
Expose Manually
Exposure compensation - Yes
Change WB
Image stabilization
Built-in flash
Hot shoe
Auto exposure bracketing
White balance bracketing
Exposure
Multisegment exposure
Average exposure
Spot exposure
Partial exposure
AF area exposure
Center weighted exposure
Video features
Supported video resolutions 1280 x 720 -
Maximum video resolution 1280x720 None
Mic support
Headphone support
Connectivity
Wireless None None
Bluetooth
NFC
HDMI
USB none USB 2.0 (480 Mbit/sec)
GPS None None
Physical
Environment sealing
Water proof
Dust proof
Shock proof
Crush proof
Freeze proof
Physical dimensions 95 x 57 x 19mm (3.7" x 2.2" x 0.7") 146 x 113 x 80mm (5.7" x 4.4" x 3.1")
DXO scores
DXO All around score not tested not tested
DXO Color Depth score not tested not tested
DXO Dynamic range score not tested not tested
DXO Low light score not tested not tested
Other
Self timer - Yes
Time lapse recording
Storage type - Compact Flash (Type I, UDMA compatible)
Card slots 1 1
Cost at launch $175 $2,339