Panasonic FP5 vs Sony HX90V: An Experienced Photographer’s In-Depth Comparison

When it comes to compact cameras that fit snugly in a pocket or small bag, the Panasonic Lumix DMC-FP5 and Sony Cyber-shot DSC-HX90V often pop up as contenders - but they couldn’t be more different beneath their similarly compact exteriors. I’ve spent extensive hands-on time with both models, putting them through their paces across multiple photography scenarios. So, if you’re hunting for a dependable, versatile compact camera, or just curious how these two stack up, this detailed comparison will walk you through everything from sensor tech and ergonomics to specialized shooting needs - all with the practical experience and insider insights you deserve.

Let’s jump right into it.

Size Matters: Pocketable Design vs. Comfortable Handling

First impressions mean a lot when choosing a travel and street-friendly camera. The Panasonic FP5 is about as slim and lightweight as they come, weighing just 141 grams and measuring 101x59x18 mm. The HX90V is larger and heftier, at 245 grams and 102x58x36 mm, which places it in the slightly bulkier compact category but still very manageable for most pockets.

The Panasonic’s ultracompact body fits effortlessly into most pockets and doesn’t scream “camera” when you're walking urban streets - a real advantage for candid street photography or quick snaps on the fly. However, its diminutive size also means fewer physical controls and a modest grip, which can feel fiddly during extended use or in colder weather when gloves come into play.

Sony’s HX90V trades some portability for better ergonomics and a more substantial grip. The thicker profile allows for a firmer hold, especially important when zoomed in at 720mm equivalent focal length, or when shooting with one hand while on the move.

If you prioritize absolute pocketability and quick grab-and-go operation, the FP5 impresses. For more balanced handling with room for fiddling manual controls amid longer outings, the HX90V’s size serves it well.

Control Layout and User Interface: Will You Miss Physical Dials?

Upon flipping both cameras open for shooting, differences in control layout become immediately clear. The FP5’s top panel is minimalist with no dedicated shutter speed or aperture dials, reflecting its target at casual users with mostly automatic exposure modes. Conversely, the HX90V provides a more nuanced command environment with physical buttons and a dial, supporting shutter priority, aperture priority, and full manual exposure modes.

This clearly shows why the Panasonic FP5 is aimed at point-and-shoot simplicity. For users who prefer to tweak settings mid-shoot, the HX90V shines, allowing quick adjustments without deep diving into menus. Plus, Sony’s tilting screen and the electronic viewfinder deliver versatile framing options and usability in challenging lighting.

The FP5 has a fixed 3-inch TFT touchscreen, which is responsive but modestly detailed at 230k dots, and lacks the touch sensitivity in autofocus or quick settings that many have come to expect. In contrast, the HX90V sacrifices touchscreen in favor of a higher-resolution (921k dots) tilting screen and an excellent 0.5x magnification EVF with 638k-dot resolution - a feature almost unheard of in this class.

Sensor and Image Quality: Small Sensors with Different Capacities

Both cameras use a 1/2.3-inch sensor size, a common choice for compact zooms, but the difference in sensor tech is crucial. The Panasonic FP5 relies on a CCD sensor with 14 megapixels, whereas the Sony HX90V employs a more modern backside-illuminated CMOS sensor packing 18 megapixels.

From my detailed lab testing and real-world shooting, the HX90V’s BSI-CMOS sensor offers superior noise handling at higher ISO levels, improved dynamic range, and a slight edge in color depth. While neither camera can compete with APS-C or full-frame sensors, the HX90V tends to deliver cleaner images in low light and better detail retention in shadows and highlights.

The FP5, while respectable in good lighting, falls behind once you push ISO past 400 or shoot into shadows. The CCD sensor renders skin tones with smooth gradations but lacks versatility across varying exposures. Also, maximum native ISO caps at 6400 on the FP5 vs. the HX90V’s 12800, which translates into more usable low-light shots on Sony’s model.

Viewing and Composing: Screen and Viewfinder Realities

The FP5’s touchscreen acts as both a framing and selection tool but doesn’t offer an electronic viewfinder (EVF). For street shooters who want quick framing and minimal fuss, this is fine - just keep in mind visibility in bright sunlight is a struggle, and with no EVF, eye-level shooting is out of the question.

The HX90V, on the other hand, boasts a built-in pop-up 638k-dot EVF with full 100% coverage and a 0.5x magnification. This is a rare offering in a small superzoom camera and extremely useful outdoors or when you want steady framing at long focal lengths.

The tilting rear screen also helps for overhead shots and low angles, providing compositional flexibility the FP5 simply can’t match.

Zoom and Lens Versatility: Reach vs Simplicity

This is where the cameras’ philosophies visibly diverge. The Panasonic FP5 sports a modest zoom range of 35-140mm equivalent with a maximum aperture range of f/3.5-5.9. This 4x zoom covers standard needs for portraits, landscapes, and casual shooting but can feel limiting if you want to get closer to distant subjects.

Sony’s HX90V bridges a staggering 24-720mm equivalent range, a massive 30x optical zoom at a similar maximum aperture range of f/3.5-6.4. From wide-angle travel vistas to distant wildlife, this range offers serious flexibility in one compact package.

The trade-off? The HX90V has a slightly slower maximum aperture at the telephoto end and more noticeable depth of field falloff. Plus, I noticed some softness creeping in at 720mm, as expected for such an extreme zoom. Nevertheless, it’s still impressively sharp throughout the range and aided by optical image stabilization.

The Panasonic has a macro minimum focus distance of 10 cm, decent for close-ups, but the Sony improves on this with 5 cm, granting more detailed close-focus capabilities for casual macro shots.

Autofocus System: Reaction Times and Accuracy

Autofocus systems can make or break a shooting experience, especially for wildlife, sports, or street photography where speed and accuracy matter.

The Panasonic FP5 employs contrast-detection AF with 11 focus points and face detection. While this works well in well-lit, static situations, I found it sluggish and prone to hunting under low light or when tracking moving subjects.

Sony’s HX90V uses a contrast-detection system but optimized with multiple focusing modes including center, multi-area, and selective AF points. It supports continuous AF allowing tracking of moving subjects better. The HX90V also features face detection and eye detection AF (though animal eye autofocus is absent in both).

In real-world use, the HX90V’s autofocus felt significantly faster and more reliable across different lighting and movement scenarios, making it a superior choice for more demanding situations like wildlife or sports.

Burst Shooting and Shutter Speeds: Speed Matters for Action

The FP5 offers 6 fps continuous shooting while the HX90V achieves 10 fps, a noticeable advantage for those chasing fleeting moments.

Regarding shutter speeds, the Panasonic caps at 1/1600s max while Sony extends up to 1/2000s - slightly better for freezing very fast motion outdoors or in bright light.

The HX90V also supports shutter priority, aperture priority, and manual modes, important for action or creative control. The FP5 lacks those modes, limiting you to mostly automatic exposure control.

Build Quality and Durability: How Tough Are They?

Both cameras are not weather-sealed or ruggedized, so neither is designed for tough environmental use. The FP5’s slim build is more vulnerable to accidental drops or impacts, while the HX90V’s chunkier body offers some additional protection thanks to its more substantial chassis.

Neither model is crushproof, waterproof, or shockproof; if you need reliability in harsh conditions, you’ll want to look elsewhere.

Video Performance: Basics vs More Capable Options

Neither camera delivers dazzling video specs by today’s standards, but there are notable differences.

Panasonic FP5 records up to 720p HD (1280 x 720) at 30 fps in Motion JPEG format. Motion JPEG is easy to edit but produces larger files and lacks advanced compression efficiency.

The Sony HX90V can record Full HD 1080p at 60, 60i, 30, or 24 fps using AVCHD and XAVC S codecs, providing more professional-quality footage with better compression. It is limited to electronic stabilization, but overall delivers superior video quality.

Neither camera has a microphone or headphone port, so for serious videographers, external audio setups are out.

Connectivity and Storage: Going Wireless and More Flexible Media

Connectivity is a clear advantage for Sony’s HX90V here. It has built-in Wi-Fi and GPS for geotagging and remote control through Sony’s apps. Panasonic’s FP5 has no wireless capabilities, meaning you must rely on physical USB connections for file transfers.

Both cameras use SD cards, but the HX90V additionally supports Memory Stick Duo, offering some additional media flexibility.

Battery life favors Sony as well, rated at 360 shots per charge vs. Panasonic’s 260, which may not sound like a lot but is significant for day-long shoots without spares.

Real-World Shooting: How They Perform Across Genres

Now, let’s get practical and talk about specific photography types:

• Portraits: The FP5’s limited zoom and simpler autofocus mean you’ll get basic skin tones but less crispness or subject separation. The HX90V’s longer zoom (up to 720 mm equiv.) allows headshots without intruding on personal space. Its more sophisticated AF with face and eye detection aids crisp portraits even in lower light. Still, neither offers large-aperture glass to deliver creamy bokeh like larger interchangeable lens cameras.

• Landscapes: Both cameras perform well for daytime landscapes. The HX90V’s higher resolution (18MP) gives a bit more room for cropping, and the wide 24mm equivalent focal length helps frame broader vistas than Panasonic’s 35mm. Neither is weather-sealed, so caution is advised in challenging conditions.

• Wildlife: The big difference is Sony’s 30x zoom versus Panasonic’s 4x. For wildlife shooting, HX90V is the obvious choice, combined with its faster autofocus and burst rates. That magnification gives you real reach for distant subjects.

• Sports: HX90V’s superior burst rate (10 fps) and AF tracking make it far better for action and sports. The FP5 lacks continuous AF, so missed moments are more common.

• Street: Panasonic’s smaller size and discreet appearance are ideal here. The HX90V is less stealthy but provides more control. Both struggle in very low-light street scenes due to sensor limitations, but the HX90V’s higher native ISO improves performance slightly.

• Macro: Sony’s 5 cm minimum focus beats Panasonic’s 10 cm, plus its longer zoom lets you frame creative details from a distance. Neither camera is specialized macro gear, but Sony’s takes the edge.

• Night/Astro: Both cameras have modest high ISO ranges, but I wouldn’t recommend either for serious astrophotography. The HX90V’s higher max ISO and manual exposure capabilities give it a slight advantage for casual night scenes.

• Video: For vloggers or casual video, Sony’s 1080p at 60 fps plus tilting screen make it a better all-rounder. Panasonic’s video mode is more limited and geared towards snapshots.

• Travel: Both cameras are portable, but FP5’s tiny size aids pocketability. HX90V’s better zoom and handling make it a versatile travel companion for diverse scenes.

• Professional: Neither camera suits high-end professional photography workflows due to sensor size and lack of RAW support. That said, HX90V’s manual controls and advanced zoom can aid pro casual shooters or journalists needing compact secondary gear.

Panasonic FP5 front Panasonic FP5 screen back Sony HX90V front Sony HX90V screen back

Here is a gallery with sample images from each camera illustrating real-world image quality, dynamic range, and color rendering.

Summary of Technical Strengths and Weaknesses

From raw performance to handling, Sony HX90V generally scores higher across the board, especially in image quality, autofocus, and video.

This chart breaks down each camera’s aptitudes across photography types. HX90V dominates in wildlife, sports, and travel niches, while FP5 remains competitive for casual street and portrait use due to its simplicity and size.

Which One Should You Choose?

If you want a simple, pocketable travel companion or street camera that fits comfortably in your hand or jacket pocket, and your photography is mostly casual snapshots in daylight, the Panasonic FP5 suits you well. It is also more budget-friendly at around $200, making it easy to replace or carry as a secondary camera.

However, if your photography needs include long zoom reach for wildlife or sports, video recording with decent quality, and you appreciate manual exposure controls along with showing off shots on the go with Wi-Fi transfers, the Sony HX90V is the smarter investment despite its higher price near $440. It offers superior image quality, better autofocus, a usable electronic viewfinder, and a flexible zoom range capable of covering every major photographic scenario from landscapes to unpredictable action.

Final Thoughts from an Experienced Reviewer

Having tested thousands of cameras over the years, I can tell you that compromises are inevitable in compacts, especially those with fixed lenses. The Panasonic FP5 is an earnest, no-nonsense camera for casual photography enthusiasts who prize convenience and pocketability above all else. It stands as a solid old-school compact whose interface and feature limitations reveal its age.

The Sony HX90V is a far more capable compact zoom by modern standards, balancing image quality, features, and zoom range admirably. Its weaknesses boil down mostly to its small sensor size and modest aperture, not unusual for pocket superzooms, but its comprehensive feature set and ergonomics make it an excellent all-rounder.

For serious enthusiasts stepping down from interchangeable lens systems, or travelers wanting an all-in-one camera without the bulk and complexity, the HX90V is the clear winner.

Dear camera manufacturers, if you could innovate a small sensor compact that combined the FP5’s pocket size with HX90V’s zoom length and manual control, I’d be quite the happy reviewer!

If you found this thorough comparison helpful, check out my video review that showcases side-by-side image samples and handling tips to go beyond the specs.

Happy shooting!

End of Article